4 ms·
Your apologism really rubs me the wrong way to be honest, and you've made such a strange, strongly-worded conclusion not at all supported by evidence. Laptops
by arcticbull 6y ago
Your apologism really rubs me the wrong way to be honest, and you've made such a strange, strongly-worded conclusion not at all supported by evidence.
Laptops with batteries, for instance, aren't "luddite" technology. Plenty of companies still make them. There's other ways of connecting a battery to chassis even in a small form factor like AirPods. For instance, a threaded base that screws in. It's not rocket science.
What you're saying is that Apple, the great innovator, can't find a way to make replaceable battery in a clean and elegant form factor for a small device, and that's the reason that nations are wealthier now than they used to be?
C'mon now, that's hard to make with a straight face isn't it? Failure is now success. Private profiteering at the expense of the environment is technophilia. Feels a lot like Owellian doublespeak to me.
tl;dr: Apple spends $16B per year on R&D. They can figure out how to screw a battery into an AirPod, and no, that's not why we're all wealthy now. It's why Apple is wealthier now.
- amluto 6y agoA non-replaceable battery in an AirPod makes perfect sense to me — AirPods are tiny. Laptops are a different story entirely.
- arcticbull 6y agoI just don't see why that's the case though, regardless of size, why fill dumps with perfectly functional technology because a consumable part is glued instead of screwed in? There's no justification, especially at the $300 price point. I guess my question is, why are you championing e-waste? What benefit do you get from losing the ability to replace a battery?
- jiggawatts 6y agoYou're thinking emotionally, not looking at the actual numbers. A laptop is a physically large device, typically in the $1000 range, and the "overhead" of a screw is negligible. Did you watch the video? AirPods are a marvel of modern engineering! They're incredibly, astonishingly packed full of fantastically miniaturised parts. This is absolute bleeding edge stuff. A screw, no matter how tiny, would absolutely be a problem. You'd also have to make the battery "loose" and not glued in, add a connector for it -- but not one that could work loose from normal shaking. This is a borderline physically impossible problem that's just not worth it to solve. What volume do you think all the AirPods in the world take up in rubbish tips? No, seriously. Let us sit down and compute this: At least one site is claiming that Apple sold 60 million AirPods in one year. The charging case is 44.3 x 21.3 x 53.5 mm and together with the two AirPods weighs 44 grams. That's 2,640 tons annually: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=44+grams+*+60+million https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=44+grams+*+60+million ... or about 20% of the trash produced by New York daily, And in terms of volume, it is a little more than the volume of an Olympic swimming pool: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=44.3+mm+*+21.3+mm+*+53.5+mm+*+60+million https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=44.3+mm+*+21.3+mm+*+53... You'd also have to factor in that adding a screw doesn't mean that 100% of all AirPods are recycled in perpetuity, but that more like 20% might have their lifespan extended one or two years at most before the owners lost or broke them. Now keep in mind that Apple sells over half of all wireless headsets globally, so the sum total annual e-waste is double those numbers above, roughly speaking. Not exactly the end of the world. Or to put it another way, I own a set of AirPod+case that weigh 44 grams. I bought them a year ago. The 4g airpods got replaced after 1 years, generating 4g of e-waste in the first year of ownership. I intend to keep these for at least one more year, generating twenty-something grams of waste in annualised terms. I just took out the family garbage today, it was several kilograms. I have a small family.
- arcticbull 6y agoI'm not approaching this emotionally. I suggest once again that defeatism and apoligism has led you to believe that Apple could build an "engineering marvel" in AirPods, but couldn't figure out a non-permanent attachment mechanism for a battery that doesn't otherwise compromise the product and the experience. Remember, we're not even talking about user-serviceable. Just, you know, serviceable. > This is a borderline physically impossible problem that's just not worth it to solve. Wouldn't you not have said the same about any aspect of AirPods before? No wire between them? Smooth hand-off? I mean, think about it, they were able to miniaturize all those parts, solve all the difficult electrical engineering and software challenges, but somehow they're just physically incapable of finding a non-permanent battery attachment mechanism? Do they not have access to all the world's best mechanical engineers? > No, seriously. Let us sit down and compute this: We agree creating tons and tons of waste, well that's bad. Where we apparently disagree is that because this is a "small" amount of waste it doesn't matter. As though a lot of small amounts of waste together do not form big waste? If we let Apple get away with building thoroughly unrepairable devices, why would we stop anyone? And suddenly we're right back where we started. Everyone needs to engineer with reparability in mind, and yes, the biggest tech company in the world is a great place to start. Especially one with 50%+ margins, as thus, could very easily afford to try. As a final note, to be clear, I didn't suggest adding a screw. I suggested threading the base. However, I am not a mechanical engineer, those are the folks who I would trust to come up with a solution to this problem. I'm not even arguing about this per se, I reject the theory that anyone who believes in reparability is a luddite and that there's no way to increase the wealth of nations without being as aggressively wasteful as possible.