5 ms·
Yes, America has the worst economic system there is except for all the others that have been tried. China? You GOT to be kidding! They are run by a one party
by NY_USA_Hacker 15y ago
Yes, America has the worst economic system there is except for all the others that have been tried.
China? You GOT to be kidding! They are run by a one party dictatorship. They run essentially a centrally directed, command economy. They are still so poor that on average they have a tough time even getting enough rice for their people.
So, starting from where they are, they can get a fantastic rate of growth basically borrowing science, technology, and finance from America. BUT: Once they quit crawling, get up on all fours, and start walking, then they will face the fact that they have some serious problems: (1) Total suckage for a constitution. (2) Similarly for their political and legal systems and human rights, e.g., little things like freedom of the press. (3) Next to nothing in 'democratic traditions'. (4) A lot of filthy air and water. (5) A population with a quite old average age.
So, once they are standing, their people will want to do things about (1)-(5). As a country, they will struggle. The struggles may become violent. On "One fine day" (I know, Japan, not China), they will get (1)-(4) solved; solving (5) will be harder.
Then they will be about where America was in, say, 1950. As they move ahead, actually to do better than America they will have to do well with things that are new, with pushing the envelope, with making progress on new ground. Then they will begin to see the enormous advantages of political freedom, freedom to cut new ground in our research universities, free enterprise, freedom of the press, freedom in art, guarantees of freedom from an oppressive government, etc. They will still have the problem of a population with too old average age and a bad ratio of people to land and natural resources.
Net, bet on the economy in China continuing to grow rapidly for some years, but don't bet on China actually beating America in any significant sense this century.
- haploid 15y agoYou seem to think that economic and military strength have political freedom as a prerequisitie. I can understand why you'd believe that, since the "good guys" just happened to win WW2 and launch American hegemony. Well, 65 years is not a very long time. The Roman, the Ottoman, and the Persian empires all had arguably less free political systems than China does today, and yet that did not prevent them from dominating large parts of the planet economically and militarily.