4 ms·
The case of questions on public boards is different, because those also serve as reference for future people with the same question. Places like SO in particula
by TeMPOraL 6y ago
The case of questions on public boards is different, because those also serve as reference for future people with the same question. Places like SO in particular exist not just to help the person asking, but the countless thousands who will find the question through Google search.
In those cases, if you do the "looking at your context, did you mean Y instead of X" substitution, your answer will be still attached to a "how to X" query, and will frustrate a lot of people who may have a legitimate reason for doing X.
- nicoburns 6y agoIMO one of the best things about Stackoverflow is that it helps all the other thousands of people who thought they needed to do X but really needed to do Y. Having the answer for "how to do Y" under the correct label would be useless to these people because they'd never know they needed to do Y. If you really do need to do X, then explain why clearly in your question and you'll likely get an answer for it. And of course SO allows multiple answers, so we can have both the technically correct and the not technically correct but still useful answers.
- scubbo 6y ago> In those cases, if you do the "looking at your context, did you mean Y instead of X" substitution, your answer will be still attached to a "how to X" query, and will frustrate a lot of people who may have a legitimate reason for doing X. And, conversely, it will help a lot of people who may not realise that their desire to do X instead of Y is flawed.
- bastijn 6y agoWhich is probably the larger population as this kind of substition happens most often when a common solution to a common problem is not used. So, when you notice this happens often and it annoys you, ask better questions. Explain what you want to achieve, what you considered and why you discarded certain solutions whilst you know they are common. If you get a substition beyond all of that chances are the person answering knows what's up. Embrace it, see why it is proposed and simply take time to explain why you couldn't use that (or can). It takes a few minutes but the person answering is spending more than you are, for free. Also you help every next viewer of your question.