5 ms·
Under PPP, the Chinese economy will expand from $11.2 trillion this year to $19 trillion in 2016. Meanwhile the size of the U.S. economy will rise from $15.2 tr
by keiferski 16y ago
Under PPP, the Chinese economy will expand from $11.2 trillion this year to $19 trillion in 2016. Meanwhile the size of the U.S. economy will rise from $15.2 trillion to $18.8 trillion. That would take America’s share of the world output down to 17.7%, the lowest in modern times. China’s would reach 18%, and rising.
So we won't be the top any longer, but we'll still be enormously dominant. So? Competition drives innovation.
All the "America is doomed" folks act as if America is going to crumble to pieces simply because we are no longer the only gorilla in the room.
- kokon 16y agoBut I think the implication is a lot more than just being the second. Once you're the second, you can't easily dictate anything anymore. Just like having multiple buyers, the seller has more options to sell the product.
- mike-cardwell 16y agoThe danger comes when China has enough money to equal the US in military strength and decides it wants as much influence in World politics as America does. The rest of the World doesn't need that complication.
- narrator 16y agoThe Chinese have not had a tradition of colonialism. They're just not as obsessed with controlling the world as the west is. They are assertive over neighboring areas that have been arguably part of China for a long time like Tibet, Taiwan, Macau and Hong Kong but that's pretty negligible compared to the global domination aspirations of the Soviets, the Axis powers or Colonial European powers.
- tybris 16y agoThey're working on it http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neocolonialism#Sino-African_relations http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neocolonialism#Sino-African_rel...
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- hvs 16y agoYeah, because we've been doing a bang up job in that department.
- tybris 16y agoI think the situation is a lot different than in the cold war. The economies of the U.S. and China are so deeply connected that neither can afford to get into a major conflict with the other.
- weavejester 16y agoI'm not convinced military power is actually that useful in the modern world. The US spends more on its military than the rest of the world combined, and yet it has trouble maintaining control in the poorest countries on Earth. I'd personally be more concerned about China's economic power, but I suspect that there's a limit to how efficient China's economy can be whilst maintaining its totalitarian state.
- hugh3 16y agoThe US spends more on its military than the rest of the world combined, and yet it has trouble maintaining control in the poorest countries on Earth. That's largely for ethical reasons though. The US is obsessed with minimising civilian casualties. If the US were as ruthless as the great empires of the past then there'd be no problem maintaining control. Trouble in this town? Destroy it! On the other hand, imperialism itself isn't all that useful in the modern world. Why did the Europeans go to all the trouble of setting up all those foreign empires? Why, so they could trade with the locals! Nowadays anyone can trade with anyone, and there's really no need to have political control over India just to trade with Indians.
- weavejester 16y agoThat's largely for ethical reasons though. The US is obsessed with minimising civilian casualties. That's certainly part of it, and I imagine that China cares far less about civilians than the US does. But I think it's also because properly motivated individuals can cause far more damage than they could do in the past. There's a lot more technology to take advantage of, and many more targets to, well, target. Nowadays anyone can trade with anyone, and there's really no need to have political control over India just to trade with Indians. I think there was a degree of "take" as well as "trade", but in general I think you're right. In the past it was easy to profit from conquest, but nowadays it isn't really cost-effective. I don't think there's been a war fought so far this century that hasn't been a huge economic loss for all involved.
- enko 16y ago> Nowadays anyone can trade with anyone, and there's really no need to have political control You're forgetting just one small thing - oil. It's still vitally necessary to the US (and everyone else). And if OPEC is left all-powerful then they can turn off the spigot at any time for any reason. Obviously Iraq is one way of getting around OPEC's power - badly misguided IMO, but undeniably successful in the narrow goal of securing a large non-OPEC source of middle eastern oil. The broader point, though, would be that without some kind of global naval "police" then anyone finding themselves in the position to block trade might decide to. The US navy has traditionally enforced, at least by implication, the "freedom to trade" you speak of. I wish they would stick to this rather noble goal!
- vessenes 16y agoThis is basically already happening, albeit mostly in places Americans don't "care" about. China has been quietly buying up most of Africa for the last decade, for instance.
- medwards 16y agoWe're not going to have another Cold War. For one thing, the American and Chinese economies are interdependent. For another, they'd both require multilateral support to act militarily in any significant capacity.
- haploid 16y agoNo. The "America is doomed" folks act as if China has far more productive capacity than we do, and that when trade and currency imbalances finally correct, we will be left in a position where it's too expensive to import the things we can no longer produce. The "America is doomed" folks act as if American culture denigrates education and intelligence to the point where "Idiocracy" is not an unthinkable future for the nation. Competition only drives innovation to the extent that one of the competitors actually has productive capacity or intellectual horsepower sufficient to actually compete. I'm no doomer, but I certainly don't think we're looking at merely not being "the only gorilla in the room".
- oostevo 16y agoThere are _huge_ economic, cultural, and military benefits to being the sole superpower that don't exist for country number two. These benefits are, in essence, virtuous cycles that give the superpower a advantages on the world stage just by virtue of already being in first place. Think of it like compound interest, or a really big ball in Katamari Damacy, only for geopolitical power. That is, the US can arrange things in its favor to make it more powerful just because it's already quite powerful and no other country is. As an example, the United States Dollar is the de-facto reserve currency for the rest of the world. That means that the US can purchase things without having to first go through (expensive) currency exchange, giving the US an economic advantage. The reserve currency status is also a major factor that also allows the US to borrow money pretty much at will. Similar arguments can be made about cultural, military, diplomatic, and other power. That means that countries aspiring to be the superpower have the deck stacked against them. So when, despite this, China overtakes the US, the US will have an awful lot of catching up to do. It's not fighting for food in the streets, but it would be a fairly serious blow to the US.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoThat means that the US can purchase things without having to first go through (expensive) currency exchange,... Expensive? The Bid/Ask spread for EUR-USD is (at the moment I write this) 1.4582-1.4584. Hedging your forex risk can be expensive, but exchange is not.
- oostevo 16y agoWell, I was thinking of relatively expensive on the scale required for country-scale commodity purchasing, but that may not be right either. Since I gather you probably know more about monetary policy than I do, how's this logic for an explanation of the benefit of reserve currency status? * Things (like oil) on global markets are traded in USD. * That means countries need to accumulate or exchange for USD in order to buy things. * This both increases the value of the USD and means the US Government can issue bonds at lower rates than they otherwise could. [Edit: formatting]
- 16y ago