22 ms·
If fuel prices double again, which they surely will do within ten years, do you really think that the automotive and aviation options are going to continue to b
by astrodust 16y ago
If fuel prices double again, which they surely will do within ten years, do you really think that the automotive and aviation options are going to continue to be inexpensive? The pressure on fuels will only get worse over time, and unless you have a better idea, high-speed rail, which can be electrified, is a far more efficient method of transport.
There are high speed rail systems that don't involve carving up tons of land, either by building on top of existing right of ways or by building it on pylons to elevate it.
- hugh3 16y agoActually it seems to me that electric cars are a more energy-efficient solution than high-speed trains. We're not that far away from the point where this becomes practical. A train might use less electricity per passenger-mile than a car when it's full, but when it's not full its efficiency goes down pretty quick because you're hauling a lot of metal around. Also there's the fundamental inefficiency of trains: they always go from somewhere that isn't exactly where you are to somewhere that isn't exactly where you want to be, on some schedule that probably doesn't exactly match what you want to do.
- tomp 16y agoThe biggest problem of electric cars is the battery (heavy, short range, short life), which is a problem electric trains don't share.
- protomyth 16y agoIf fuel prices double again and we do not have a clear replacement for our liquid fuel / road infrastructure, then food production / transportation is going to be a problem and more rail isn't the solution to that.
- hugh3 16y agoActually, a single doubling of fuel prices probably isn't a big problem for food prices, not in the US, where food is a tiny portion of most folks' budget.
- protomyth 16y agoI would disagree. Not only from the transportation cost perspective, but from: fertilizer, drying cost, food used to make fuel, feed costs and other downstream inflation.