3 ms·
I think the goals here are laudable, but the cynic in me worries about the details. Data portability is easy to implement (and has been by some companies). Bu
by crazygringo 6y ago
I think the goals here are laudable, but the cynic in me worries about the details.
Data portability is easy to implement (and has been by some companies).
But back-end interoperability and delegability are tricky not just because of technical challenges (those can be solved), but mainly because of abuse and spam.
If, all of a sudden, any other service can like and comment on Facebook posts without having a Facebook account... I don't see how this doesn't become a spam/abuse-fest overnight.
My $0.02 is that there's a much simpler solution hiding in plain sight: just stop giving legal copyright/hacking/ToS protection to sites with third-party-generated content that the site didn't license.
In other words, if someone wants to build an app that downloads your Spotify playlist data by impersonating you... or scrape Craigslist listings... or copy Yelp reviews... then nothing is legally in the way. Not copyright, not anti-hacking laws, not ToS.
Services are free to rate-limit or ban you if they catch you... but if you can get around that then the information/interaction is yours.
This feels like a much more "free market" approach. It doesn't rely on trying to build laws that will be bad compromises and outdated by the time they're passed. Rather it involves undoing existing laws and protections that are producing harm.
(To be clear, copyright still applies to things that are paid for or licensed -- movies, songs, articles, etc.)
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoBanning people using an API doesn't sound very free market The ideas of "Free market" evolved before EULA type bullshit did, I don't think original creators of the idea would approve of them.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- crazygringo 6y agoTo the contrary -- the "free" in "free market" refers to freedom. So if a service wants to ban a user, then that's pretty much the definition of a free market. Similarly, a user is free to try to get around the ban by using a different IP address, etc. Both sides here would be free to do what they want without the law taking sides. But at a technical level, because anti-scraping measures aren't that hard to defeat, it means that users and competitors will be the primary beneficiaries here.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoSo I am ok to use my 'freedom' and pay someone to cut your supply of cement, so that you can't compete with me in construction? Where is the boundary between 'free market' and narket manipulation, and how do you prove the latter? This happens all the time, Intel, paid computer manufacturers not to use AMD chips. As for the bans and circumvention idea - I would like a stable and reliable system that's guaranteed to work, not a constant game of cat and mouse.
- klyrs 6y ago> I would like a stable and reliable system that's guaranteed to work, not a constant game of cat and mouse. I'd love if the internet wasn't a neverending cat and mouse game... but what about spam?
- klyrs 6y ago"If you're going to be an asshole to my customers, gtfo of my bar" predates the concept of an EULA, and IMO, the freedom of association is a necessary component of a free market.
- sjy 6y agoThe article advocates for this, calling it “competitive compatibility,” but noting “it’s not enough to legalize competitive compatibility, since the platforms have such an advantage in technical resources that serious competitors’ attempts to interoperate face enormous engineering challenges.”
- crazygringo 6y agoInteresting, but I don't buy it. The existence of "youtube-dl" and scraping tools shows that, actually, it's the competitors who usually win. The fact is, if a service works for users at all, it's never going to be terribly difficult to scrape. That's the whole point of why it's ultimately far more beneficial for users and competitors.
- vharuck 6y agoIt's almost the inverse of websites being too powerful to compete with. The people scraping data are too small to bother with. It might be a problem if it becomes too widespread because of the legislation. The music industry survived Napster and file sharing because it had other revenue paths. But I guess if Facebook fell to an alternative way to interact which Facebook couldn't afford to stop, then that'd just be the free market at work.
- xg15 6y ago> Services are free to rate-limit or ban you if they catch you... but if you can get around that then the information/interaction is yours. So what you're saying is, you'd like to encourage a technological arms race between intrusion detection systems and hackers, without any legal repercussions for either side - and this should somehow be in the interests of users. I don't know why we'd need a "free market" approach, but this is just lawlessness. The result will be that legitimate users get the worst of both worlds: If I want to download my own Spotify playlist myself, I'll be out of luck - because my dead-simple Wget call will be no match for Spotify's bot detection. There is nothing I could legally do to make Spotify give me a copy of my own playlist - I'll have to pay some third-party service that has the necessary know-how to evade the detection and scrape the data for me. Meanwhile, some hacker could use the same service to impersonate me or steal my data - and I'd again have no legal recourse because, hey, no protection, what the hacker did was perfectly legal. Why would I want any of this?
- crazygringo 6y agoWe already have that technological arms-race, and users already win. Just look at the continuing existence of "youtube-dl" for example. Fundamentally services can't be too restrictive and still work, so users come out ahead. Also while hacking into a system is legal, theft/fraud/etc. is not. If the hacker does anything with your data, there are already laws against that.
- Reelin 6y ago> Just look at the continuing existence of "youtube-dl" for example. That only exists because Google can't be bothered to break it. There isn't currently any serious attempt at an arms race taking place there as far as I can tell. It's agent doesn't look anything like a regular browser and the way it hits their backend is nowhere near the way the official js player does, yet it continues to work for me. If an arms race ever did take place my money is (sadly) 100% on Google. Just look at the level of automated obfuscation Snapchat employs. You could reasonably expect the equivalent of a WASM based video player compiled with a custom equivalent to OLLVM, communicating with a procedurally generated API, and updated versions of API and player automatically rolled out hourly with a small overlap (equivalent to certificate renewal). (Something vaguely resembling the above is already employed for the reCAPTCHA check boxes IIUC.)