5 ms·
The cause of this is: * Android needs to know if a wifi network is working, since many wifi networks are broken and connecting to them degrades the user experi
by londons_explore 6y ago
The cause of this is:
* Android needs to know if a wifi network is working, since many wifi networks are broken and connecting to them degrades the user experience.
* Normally it does that by connecting to google.com, and if the connection succeeds, assume wifi is good to go.
* Google.com is blocked in china, meaning wifi would be broken in China.
* To fix this, Samsung has replaced google.com with qq.com in china.
* Samsung also needs to add a new DNS server to resolve qq.com, in case the network doesn't provide a DNS server and androids default of Google DNS is used (which is also blocked in China). Adding it last means it won't be used unless other DNS servers are broken.
Overall, this behaviour seems like the simplest and most logical fix Samsung could put in place to enable their users to use phones in China.
They could have run their own servers (but that would also have privacy issues), or they could have removed captive portal/bad network detection, but that probably would have broken some apps and led to unhappy users.
I can't see any other real fix in this case, and I certainly don't see any malicious intent in any of their actions.
- culturestate 6y ago> They could have run their own servers This is exactly what Apple does, and they even include some fallback domains in case apple.com doesn't resolve. Samsung's design seems less like the most logical solution than it does the laziest solution.
- SaltyBackendGuy 6y ago> laziest solution. Maybe. But also probably shortest path, least amount of risk and resource investment.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- culturestate 6y agoI mean, Samsung is one of the largest companies in the world and they already run a global cloud infrastructure to support their electronics division. I can't imagine that a PM who really cared would have much trouble getting a couple of endpoints provisioned if he or she wanted them. The more likely scenario is that they came up with what they thought was a good-enough solution and just moved on without really considering the knock-on effects.
- curryst 6y agoYou need really high reliability for that; if those endpoints go down, none of your customers' phones will connect to wifi until you fix them. People would be extremely upset they thought they were on wifi but they were really blowing through their data.
- notRobot 6y ago> shortest path, least amount of risk and resource investment. That is laziness.
- vinay427 6y agoThey said "also," and didn't deny that it may be lazy. Since when is the lazy solution, by this definition, also automatically the illogical (or even "bad") one?
- est31 6y agoGoogle might be blocked in mainland China, but is it blocked in Hong Kong? This page [0] says that Google isn't because HK is not behind the great firewall, but there are recent reports that the GFW was extended to HK as well [1], so maybe that page is outdated? But if Google had been blocked at a network level, then it would likely have made much larger headlines. Also, the author talks about Google play still being a present thing, not something unavailable to them. [0]: https://www.comparitech.com/privacy-security-tools/blockedinchina/google/ https://www.comparitech.com/privacy-security-tools/blockedin... [1]: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/jul/08/china-great-firewall-descends-hong-kong-internet-users https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/jul/08/china-great-fi...
- culturestate 6y agoNo, the GFW doesn't exist in HK (yet). GFW-compatible fallbacks are worth worrying about in HK, though, because in normal times there is a massive amount of cross-border travel between HK and SZ. Combine that with grey market HK phones being smuggled onto the mainland to avoid tax, and it's a pretty good bet that any phone destined for HK will makes its way across the border at some point. If you roam on the mainland with a HK SIM you actually hop the GFW automatically, but most people swap SIMs at the border so that isn't reliable.
- captn3m0 6y ago> If you roam on the mainland with a HK SIM you actually hop the GFW automatically This is quite interesting. So GFW is applied by ISPs exclusively on domestic SIMs? Does this mean any international SIMs on roaming hop the GFW?
- londons_explore 6y agoYes.
- e_y_ 6y agoI think the traffic gets proxied (not sure if it's encrypted) back to servers run by your home carrier. So conversely if you use a China Mobile SIM in Hong Kong or overseas your traffic gets firewalled.
- lanevorockz 6y agoIt's sad that people apparently see as ok for China to break international treaties related with HK. It's just a matter of time until all our life is controlled by big tech.
- yegle 6y agoAlso: any DNS outside of Mainland China may get blocked by GFW later, breaking millions of users in China instantly. Looks like the safest way is to use a DNS in Mainland China.
- grecy 6y agoThat explains perfectly why they do it in China. It does not explain why they do it in HK. HK is not China.
- phkahler 6y agoAnd if the GFW comes to HK and your phone doesn't work any more, how you gonna get an update with this after it happens?
- nogabebop23 6y agoThis sort of large and noisy canary is exactly what the world needs more of. How many more people will scream and protest if their phone stops working due to China's actions, vs the vague and abstract cause of "Privacy"? It will also direct their wraith at the correct target.
- LorenPechtel 6y agoI'll half agree. This seems to me to just be a case of incompetent design rather than intentional evil. It's not a good solution but it's a workable solution--but whoever did it didn't realize it didn't need to be applied in Hong Kong.
- shalmanese 6y agoQQ DNS servers are available in HK and the Mainland, Google servers are available only in HK. A significant fraction of phones bought in HK end up in the mainland so it's prudent to pick the most interoperable option.
- Ihfhcub 6y agoYou do know HK had an different government than communist China, no? That recently lost its independence but is still mostly functioning. Most Americans I talk to seem oblivious to this
- nohypercorrect 6y agoHong Kong is not affected by GFW. So it is not the cause.