6 ms·
High-speed rail: China: 5000 miles US: 0 miles There's only so much money. The US needs to build infrastructure, and other things that will grow its economy
by melling 16y ago
High-speed rail:
China: 5000 miles
US: 0 miles
There's only so much money. The US needs to build infrastructure, and other things that will grow its economy.
- dkokelley 16y agoSpace exploration has a well-documented track record of advancing technologies for us back on earth, and for a fraction of what some of our domestic projects cost.
- simpleTruth 16y agoNASA cost 4.4% of Fed Budget in 1966, that's a LOT of roads. In 2008 it's 0.6% of Fed Budget which is still a lot of roads. But more importantly: The NASA budget is larger than the National Science Foundation budget,[2] but only 61% of the National Institutes of Health budget. NASA does some interesting science but the focus is clearly on keeping the public entertained and not say lowering the cost to orbit which would be of great value.
- muhfuhkuh 16y agoGovernment has never, ever been in the business of lowering the cost of anything (except corn and wheat). It's in the business of creating infrastructure, protecting its people, looking out for the "general welfare" (which should include health, but I digress...), and demonstrating the efficacy of things ("hey, now, would ya lookie there. We got a man on the moon. Huh, go figure" or "hey, you hear that University scientist and the NIH just cured Polio? No, really, they did!"). Now, the technology transfer of government output to the private market, that's where the lowered cost and great value will come to the fore. I'm sure I'll rile the free market feathers by saying this, but SpaceX and Virgin Galactic would not exist without NASA. No way, no how. Just to get you geeked out about NASA, though, here's a fan-made video on Youtube: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NXkuo1yihjs http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NXkuo1yihjs Jersey Shore-style Fist-pumping science.
- simpleTruth 16y agoThe government breaks up monopolies to lower prices. The government builds new roads to lower transportation costs. NASA spent a less than 1 shuttle mission worth of funding to research scram jets over 7 years. Resulting in the X-43 which hit Mach 9.68 using an air breathing engine. , NASA Dryden engineers said that they expected all of their efforts to culminate in the production of a two-stage-to-orbit crewed Vehicle in about 20 years. However, the program was canceled, so, in the end you could be right Still, scramjet's are one of the few technology's to be able to reduce the cost to orbit to 1/10th - 1/100th of current costs and instead people want to wast billions trying to build a moon base? PS: The whole point of infrastructure is to lower prices. People could drive across the country before the interstate system, but it suddenly became cheaper and faster in large part because you could avoid stoplights and pedestrians etc.
- billswift 16y ago>The government breaks up monopolies to lower prices. That has happened occasionally (AT&T), but the more usual situation (Standard Oil, Alcoa Aluminum) is that prices go up, which isn't surprising since the main beneficiaries of "anti-monopoly" laws are the competitors who cannot compete with the "monopolist".
- patrickk 16y agoA quick googling of "nasa developed technologies" revealed some interesting links. http://spaceplace.nasa.gov/en/kids/spinoffs2.shtml http://spaceplace.nasa.gov/en/kids/spinoffs2.shtml http://www.sti.nasa.gov/tto/ http://www.sti.nasa.gov/tto/ http://www.sti.nasa.gov/tto/Spinoff2009/pdf/Brochure_09_web.pdf http://www.sti.nasa.gov/tto/Spinoff2009/pdf/Brochure_09_web.... I would guess that on balance, investments in NASA have resulted in a highly positive (direct and indirect) ROI for America and indeed the rest of the world. Perhaps the benefits aren't communicated as well as they could be.
- spoiledtechie 16y agoI don't personally feel building infrastructure helps the US grow its economy. What does this even entail? Faster Network speeds: yes Build more highways: no Building highspeed rail: no Building a better way to transport things: yes building intellectual property: yes The point is, what sort of infrastructure does the US actually need to build? I personally believe more roads is not one of those things that we should be trying to build. Pretty sure the highway system does an excellent job already.
- simpleTruth 16y ago"Pretty sure the highway system does an excellent job already." Have you even been in heavy Traffic congestion? The Texas Transportation Institute estimated that, in 2000, the 75 largest metropolitan areas experienced 3.6 billion vehicle-hours of delay, resulting in 5.7 billion U.S. gallons (21.6 billion liters) in wasted fuel and $67.5 billion in lost productivity, or about 0.7% of the nation's GDP. Note: That cost is significantly larger than NASA's ~$19B budget. PS: Simply building more or wider roads does not automatically remove congestion in the long term. However, mass transit really does help. Just look at how much more people are willing to pay to live near a subway station.
- protomyth 16y agoRail might work in some parts of the country, but after seeing the money spent on the light rail in the Twin Cities (MN), I am pretty sure the expansion of the 494 / 694 loop did more good. If the light rail money had been spent on another loop around the cities, it would have been better spent.
- hugh3 16y agoAw geez, not another high-speed-rail argument. The US does not have, and will never have, an effective high-speed-rail network. Nor does it really need one. You can already get from every city to every other city in a slow convenient way (car) or a fast inconvenient way (plane), and there's no real need for a third method intermediate in speed. Have you ever been at a total loss to figure out how to get from one city to another conveniently? I haven't. The Chinese government can build high speed rail, cuz it doesn't mind ripping up the houses of hundreds of thousands of people to build dead-straight rail lines into the middle of cities. The US, at this stage, has far too much investment in its cities to rip 'em up just so that I can get from San Francisco to Los Angeles in four hours (instead of seven hours, or one hour).
- melling 16y agoLA to San Francisco is about 350 miles. That's a 90 minute train ride. Beijing to Shanghai is about 820 miles. This will take about 4 hours when the trains comes online in June, a year ahead of schedule.
- jat850 16y agoI apologize but I do not understand your post. Are you saying LA to San Francisco is 350 miles and currently a 90 minute train ride (233mph) - contrasted against Beijing to Shanghai (205mph). So the high speed rail in China is slower? I realize I must have misunderstood something here. Also, I don't know California geography very well, nor the existing modes/means of transportation between those two locations. Can you clarify the point of your post here?
- melling 16y agoI was explaining how long it should take using high-speed rail. The person to which I was responding stated that the trip would be 4 hours instead of 7. High-speed rails go around 200mph, however the next gen Chinese will be around 230mph.
- 16y ago
- protomyth 16y agoAt our current place, we need to keep the current infrastructure repaired and working and start reducing the money government spends. Tax history shows we get about 15 - 20% GDP in taxes for the last 70 years. High speed rail is a huge expenditure the federal government needs to skip for now. How many miles of fibre can be paid for per mile of high speed rail?
- tdfx 16y agoI'm not sure whether your comment is against Moon colonization specifically or more generally against the use of funds for space exploration. In the case of the former I don't know enough about the potential of such a mission to pass judgment on it. In the case of the latter, however, I find that those who oppose space exploration in favor of using the funds for the good of humanity now (feeding staving people, building domestic infrastructure, eliminating innumerable other social ailments) are only shortchanging future generations of our children by guaranteeing their extinction. Very smart people have repeatedly warned us that we cannot remain a single planet species and expect a future. I really can't think of anything more important to spend money on than the only technology that will be able to allow our species to survive.
- spot 16y agothere are two problems with your argument: 1) the technology we have now is inadequate for serious colonization. we are better off investing in basic science, education, health care, and the economy in general. we have to create the people who will create the science first. 2) NASA is the wrong way to do colonization, it should be private enterprise, which has a much higher appetite for risk.
- rbanffy 16y ago> There's only so much money Cut funding from the military. Entering less wars would also do wonders to your relationship with other countries.
- jacoblyles 16y agoDon't look now, but the Chinese agency responsible for building high speed rail has wracked up $271 billion(!) in debt and train speeds have been slowed to 30 MPH[1]. A side note, I picked this up at National Review's "The Corner" blog, which is always entertaining. [1]http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/chinas-train-wreck/2011/04/21/AFqjRWRE_story.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/chinas-train-wreck/20...
- melling 16y agoYou read it wrong. That's slowed by 30mph. I think the desired speed is now around 198mph, right?