5 ms·
Bill introduced directing NASA to establish a moon base
- sixtofour 16y ago"As its text notes, a return to the Moon has been a Congressional priority several times before; that didn't stop Obama from dismissing it with "We've been there."" We've been to Oregon too, with Lewis and Clark. Fortunately, we went back.
- hugh3 16y agoWould we have been back to Oregon, though, if it turned out not to be a lush temperate land of conifer forests, rivers and flat arable soil, but a blazing hot/freezing cold dangerously-irradiated vacuum composed of a mix of rocks and much smaller rocks?
- Anon84 16y agowell... we did go back to New Mexico, Utah and the other desert states...
- starwed 16y agoI've actually seen arguments that we shouldn't really have settlements in those areas -- more lush states aren't short of space, and it takes a large amount of infrastructure to make it work.
- neworbit 16y agoYou could say the same thing about Los Angeles (massive water requirements over and above what native supply provides) but I don't see us abandoning that particular location anytime soon either. (Edit: clarified LA to Los Angeles)
- hugh3 16y agoI think this argument is silly in the context of the American southwest, but may very well make a lot of sense for the goddamn moon.
- samlevine 16y agoWhich are all vastly easier to supply and develop than the moon. So are the north and south poles, the middle of the pacific ocean and the himalayas. I get that putting meat on the ground can have benefits that probes don't provide. I also get that we have to move some people off of this rock in case it gets hit by a bus. But doing something because "it's there" won't ever get sustainable colonies, let alone self sufficient ones. We built a trillion dollar rocket industry so we could blow up the world if the russians invaded europe. Not because we wanted to advance humanity. Not because we really wanted to do something awesome. If you want humans in space en masse you have to come up with a compelling short term reason to do so. Water on the moon doesn't cut it.
- rbanffy 16y agoOTOH, a place with abundant solar energy, unexplored mineral deposits, amenable to several fabrication processes (easy to obtain high-grade vacuum), with easy access to space (low escape velocity) and a very good place to build and place telescopes with much easier access by maintenance crews (a moon buggy instead of a shuttle) seems a winner. What you call "rocks" I call "minerals".
- btilly 16y agoAsteroids have all of the same advantages. The greater distance is made up for by not having to transport goods back up out of the Moon's gravity well.
- rbanffy 16y agoNo gravity may be worse for many industrial processes than a low gravity. One problem is that you can't count on convection to arrange hot/cold fluids and have to pump everything. You also cannot count on bubbles accumulating on the top of structures and have to take measures to prevent their formation or just engineer your systems to live with them. You also cannot rely on stuff staying put because everything wants to float away. With plentiful materials and energy combined with a more or less static position in relation to Earth (the Earth is always in the same position in the lunar sky), a magnetic rail launch system becomes an easy option. You only have to carry fuel (or engines) if you intend to enter Earth orbit. If a landing is enough, you can aerobrake on Earth's atmosphere and parachute (or glide) down.
- melling 16y agoHigh-speed rail: China: 5000 miles US: 0 miles There's only so much money. The US needs to build infrastructure, and other things that will grow its economy.
- dkokelley 16y agoSpace exploration has a well-documented track record of advancing technologies for us back on earth, and for a fraction of what some of our domestic projects cost.
- simpleTruth 16y agoNASA cost 4.4% of Fed Budget in 1966, that's a LOT of roads. In 2008 it's 0.6% of Fed Budget which is still a lot of roads. But more importantly: The NASA budget is larger than the National Science Foundation budget,[2] but only 61% of the National Institutes of Health budget. NASA does some interesting science but the focus is clearly on keeping the public entertained and not say lowering the cost to orbit which would be of great value.
- muhfuhkuh 16y agoGovernment has never, ever been in the business of lowering the cost of anything (except corn and wheat). It's in the business of creating infrastructure, protecting its people, looking out for the "general welfare" (which should include health, but I digress...), and demonstrating the efficacy of things ("hey, now, would ya lookie there. We got a man on the moon. Huh, go figure" or "hey, you hear that University scientist and the NIH just cured Polio? No, really, they did!"). Now, the technology transfer of government output to the private market, that's where the lowered cost and great value will come to the fore. I'm sure I'll rile the free market feathers by saying this, but SpaceX and Virgin Galactic would not exist without NASA. No way, no how. Just to get you geeked out about NASA, though, here's a fan-made video on Youtube: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NXkuo1yihjs http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NXkuo1yihjs Jersey Shore-style Fist-pumping science.
- 16y ago
- neworbit 16y agoNow I like the idea of a moon base and space research as much as the next engineer (and we here at HN seem pretty friendly to it) but I have the general impression that without commensurate investment, this is on par with saying "NASA is directed to clone unicorns"
- hugh3 16y agoPretty much, though not exactly. NASA is, after all, made up of a vast number of people competing to get their own favourite projects funded. If a directive comes down from on high that NASA's primary goal is to build a moonbase then it means that projects relevant to this goal start getting funded (and that projects irrelevant to this goal get a hasty rewrite to make 'em sound like they're relevant to this goal).
- martin1b 16y agoWhy again do we want to build a base on a big rock? And why do we fund NASA for $20 billion/year? Especially in a struggling economy? Why doesn't some other country step up to do this if it's so important? It seems the US spends money on everybody except itself. Yet, we're the target for every criticism, while others stand practically idle.
- civilian 16y agoWe should be putting funding into a space elevator. Moving things into space with rockets will be always be incredibly expensive and inefficient. If a space elevator were built, moon (and mars) bases would easily be built, almost as an afterthought. ("Oh yeah, I guess it is easy to do this now...") Currently, all of our space vehicles are also built to withstand atmospheric exit & entry. With a space elevator, we could afford to have elevator -> moon or earth-elevator -> mars-moon/station transports that would be much easier to build. If there is any foolish government project I am willing to put my tax dollars into, it's this.