4 ms·
> Companies that make their money selling ads Which includes...the New York Times. And all other media companies. > This business model should be illegal. It'
by pdonis 6y ago
> Companies that make their money selling ads
Which includes...the New York Times. And all other media companies.
> This business model should be illegal. It's already trivially unethical.
By this criterion, pretty much all newspapers that have ever existed should be illegal. Also pretty much all TV channels. If this is a problem, it's been a problem since long before Facebook and Twitter.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- thesagan 6y agoIt's a problem. Been one since the Spanish-American war. Some of the biggest source of advertising revenues for news media organizations comes from defense companies. The New York Times pushed for the Iraq war, for example. They fired journalists who reported dovish news, too. Many others left to report as freelancers so they could paint more accurate pictures in smaller publications. Similarly, MSNBC will bring on ex-Pentagon officials to "analyze" current events, but they don't bring in ex-State Department officials. There are likely patterns and incentives here. "Follow the money" as they like to say.
- glial 6y agoYeah, there’s a terrible conflict of interest between informing the public and selling advertising. There has been for a long time. It’s just worse now. We should figure out how to fix it rather than throw up our hands.
- josquindesprez 6y agoI'd honestly have a hard time making a case that Fox News is less net bad for society than Facebook as of today. But Fox News feels like the "end-stage" version of whatever you'd call that particular flavor of classic corruption and human-brain-hijacking, whereas Facebook has been visibly improving its algorithmic behavior control abilities, has already invented new flavors of human-brain-hijacking, and seems to be getting better and better at making us worse every day. We've learned how to handle the old style of human-brain-hijacking. Those lessons were written in blood and war. Facebook has few parallels, only distant rumblings of far worse lessons to be learned.
- pdonis 6y ago> I'd honestly have a hard time making a case that Fox News is less net bad for society than Facebook as of today. If you were to put "any media outlet" in place of "Fox News", I would agree with you. Part of the problem is that so many people think it's only the media outlets that say things they disagree with that are the problem. It isn't. It's all of them, no matter what side they're on or what point of view they're advancing. They will all lie and manipulate when it suits them.
- adamsea 6y ago> They will all lie and manipulate when it suits them. Absolutely. At the same time I think it makes sense to single out Fox News at this current moment. For several years now they have they been a straight-up propaganda mouthpiece. They’re noticeably worse. I’d call myself a Progressive, but FWIW as a habit I don’t watch any television news regularly - I read. Point being I think it’s reasonable to say that you can’t say with a straight face that Fox News is - at this particular moment - equivalent to other networks.
- rayiner 6y agoFox News isn’t designed to be even handed. “Fair and Balanced” is an inside joke. It’s designed to bring balance to a media industry that skews heavily left by offering the countervailing view on issues. (I do agree it’s gone downhill since Ailes left. Megyn Kelly has said as much.) To put it differently: you cannot understand what’s going on in the world just reading the NYT and watching CNN, especially in the Trump era. Those outlets may oftentimes be closer to the truth in their conclusions, but they’ll completely strip context and nuance from issues in favor of preferred narrative. CNN will happily air a video with buildings burning in the background and “mostly peaceful protests” in the chyron: https://www.foxnews.com/media/cnn-panned-for-on-air-graphic-reading-fiery-but-mostly-peaceful-protest-in-front-of-kenosha-fire; https://www.foxnews.com/media/cnn-panned-for-on-air-graphic-... https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/only-some-kinds-of-protest-are-always-mostly-peaceful https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/only-some-kinds-of-pro.... One thing that’s remarkable is that in the last 6 months, I’ve had Democrats confide to me that they’re harboring skepticism of the media because they noticed how much the media downplayed the violence of what was happening in their cities.
- throwaway13337 6y agoAbsolutely. Media - especially news media - wherein the product is advertising has always had a perverse incentive structure to stir up society to get more eyeballs. Key in this is the insight that what keeps humans engaged most is angry righteousness and tribalism. The difference is that media never had the tools that are now available to track, optimize for engagement, and also amplify that engagement with immediate social sharing. With this toolbox, we've created something that can cause society to destroy itself - the stakes are really that high. It's not the intention of the media companies but it is the result. Nothing in this world scares me more than particularly our tools created by first social media companies in their compacity to destroy civilization.
- engineer_22 6y agoNationalize Facebook.
- mths 6y agoNot to speak for GP, but I think what he's getting at is that the application of AI in this business model in order to drive engagement (for the purpose of selling ads) should be illegal. Or more generally, we need regulation around AI.
- Igelau 6y agoThis is the Alignment Problem Lite. Instead of an AGI sending the harvester drones to turn us all into paperclips, we have ML harvesting our sanity for clicks and views.
- kgwxd 6y agoNewspapers and TV channels are curated and the means to being a publisher or advertiser on those platforms is extremely limited compared to what the internet allows. When everyone on the planet is an unchecked publisher and/or advertiser, the problem is clearly much worse.
- hnaa 6y agoThe problem is that moderation doesn't scale. Newspapers, TV, radio, film all evolved to have or to conform to some kind of standards and practices department, which played well with advertiser needs. The issue with contemporary media companies is that it's not practical to do that at Internet scale -- see all of the routine stories about moderation teams at Facebook, for instance.
- echelon 6y ago>> Companies that make their money selling ads > Which includes...the New York Times. And all other media companies. Netflix? It doesn't have to be so. But you have to pay for the product.
- CinchWrench 6y agoYou nailed this. What all of these pearl-clutching arguments amount to is former gatekeepers kvetching about there no longer being a gate for them to keep. The information dissemination landscape is evolving, and we are only being held back by those too cowardly to let go of their control and let us grow and ascend.