4 ms·
> Can you name another communicable disease where "herd immunity through natural propagation" is the recommended treatment? This was the standard of care for c
by loeg 6y ago
> Can you name another communicable disease where "herd immunity through natural propagation" is the recommended treatment?
This was the standard of care for chickenpox (herpes zoster, aka shingles) until 10 or 20 years ago, for example. Sure, the mortality rate is lower, especially among healthy children.
- joshuamorton 6y ago> until 10 or 20 years ago You're off by a decade and possibly two. I'm older than 20, I was vaccinated for Chickenpox. The vaccine has been commercially available for 35 years. So I'd reiterate the question.
- Izkata 6y ago~20 years ago, naturally getting it was the go-to in our area. The idea was "let's just get it over with", because the vaccine isn't 100% effective.
- loeg 6y agoI'm less than a decade older than you (younger than 35!) and was intentionally exposed to chickenpox as a child at the advice of my pediatrician in the Seattle area. And I've had shingles in my 20s as well, so I'm certainly pro-vaccine. There may have been a vaccine 35 years ago (I'll take your word for it), but it was not the standard of care even ~25 years ago. (And to be clear, I'm not advocating for exposing people to COVID, at all. You asked a very broad question upthread with an easy counter-example — chickenpox — and I provided the counterexample.)
- hifly 6y agoThat’s complicated though. Getting it as an adult is REALLY nasty, hence the previous history to try and get it done as a kid. Now we immunise instead...
- ElCapitanMarkla 6y agoThe govt offers chickenpox vaccines here in NZ for kids now. I think it has been a fairly recent addition to the vaccination schedule but it was definitely there 3 years ago when sprog number one arrived.
- loeg 6y agoSure, it’s been standard of care in the US for a while as well. I’m glad! That change happened sometime after my childhood.