2 ms·
I really like those. Verifiability and paper trail seem very important. I’d recommending not using the term accountability if these are the things you mean.
by zepto 6y ago
I really like those. Verifiability and paper trail seem very important.
I’d recommending not using the term accountability if these are the things you mean. Generally it has the connotation of being responsible for outcomes.
I also think that there is possibly a false dichotomy between free speech and news here. As if regulating news is somehow the same thing as curtailing free speech. I’m not sure it needs to be so stark.
If we introduced some or all of these regulations, we could simply attach them to the use of ‘news’ as a product description. I.e. If you don’t do these things, you can’t sell a product called news.
This would be similar to not being able to call yourself a medical doctor or police officer without he right credentials.
As far as I can see free speech is a red-herring. We should preserve it strongly, but also introduce a category of media product that has certain guarantees or protections.
- dagmx 6y agoThe main point of the article is that the free speech laws in this country have clouded the divide between free speech for individuals, and the rights for media companies and political parties to spread misinformation as they see fit. What you're proposing in your last paragraph is what the article is proposing too. The issue is that under the guise of an absolutist take of free speech, we've now put all free speech under the same banner. To apply protections to the categories of media would require rethinking what free speech means and who it applies to. IMHO free speech is great. It just needs certain measures around transparency and corporate lobbying to prevent it being brought down with the bad actors
- zepto 6y agoI actually don’t see the article proposing what I am proposing. For the most part it is a good analysis, but I don’t see much about defining what ‘news’. The New York Times isn’t the fountain of garbage that Fox News can be, but neither is it any more principled. It’s just usually better. They have a vested interest in this being about social media rather than news, and the article focuses tech rather than news when it comes to solutions. I didn’t see where they addressed the issue of what to do about Fox News, for example.