4 ms·
Just because the law forces them to make the money available doesn't prevent them from putting a big warning on the associated transaction. Clearly, the bank k
by Nextgrid 6y ago
Just because the law forces them to make the money available doesn't prevent them from putting a big warning on the associated transaction.
Clearly, the bank knows how cheques work and how they can bounce 6 months down the line. They should make it clear to the user with a warning explaining "we are required to make this money available to you by law now, but this money can be taken back at anytime if the cheque ends up being fraudulent, and this can happen for up to 6 months down the line".
The bank also knows (doing otherwise would make me doubt their competence to operate a bank) that this is a common scam and should similarly warn their customers about it. They also know (and have the data) to prove that a lot of people fall victim to this scam suggesting that there is a lack of knowledge in the majority of people when it comes to how cheques work and how they can bounce down the line after the money has already "cleared".
Finally, when it comes to the law, the law was most likely drafted at a time where 1) there were no easier ways to transfer money instantly while making sure it's actually legitimate, so it was a necessary trade-off and 2) there were similarly no easy ways to irreversibly transfer money out of the country in an untraceable fashion, so that the majority of occurrences of such scams would also give better chance to law enforcement to actually trace the funds and make the victim whole, so the fact that someone could temporarily end up out of pocket was also not a big deal.
Nowadays that particular law is clearly inadequate and is doing more harm than good, but laws take time to change (and no doubts there are vested interests at play that would want the system to remain as-is) and there's nothing preventing the banks doing their own part to "patch" the bug until a proper fix can be installed (by deprecating the whole cheque system altogether).
- Silhouette 6y agoIt amazes me that in 2020, we still struggle to implement a simple system where someone can reliably and permanently transfer money to someone else as the default, expected behaviour of the financial system. There are far too many scams based on someone thinking they've got money they haven't, whether it's person-to-person because of weirdness about reversible money moves or someone successfully abusing some sort of chargeback or dispute mechanism against a merchant. It's not as if these things aren't well known by the industry. It just chooses not to do anything about them, and to continue to rely on fundamentally insecure and unreliable methods of moving money around when it is perfectly capable of implementing better ones.
- jivings 6y agoWe have this system though, it's just we also still support systems that should have deprecated a long time ago for being insecure.
- Silhouette 6y agoWe have this system though Are you sure? You're certainly correct that many popular payment methods are well overdue for being discontinued, but many methods of transferring money that you might think are permanent or even immediate can, under some circumstances, subsequently be reversed. Unless you've been the victim who sent money to a scammer, of course, in which case all too often it mysteriously turns out that the method you used doesn't suffer from such a limitation. It's almost as if there's a whole dark industry of people who know which methods can be exploited like this and use it to abuse innocent people who made reasonable but incorrect assumptions about the competence and security of the financial services industry.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoHave you ever heard of a money order or wire transfer being reversed?
- Silhouette 6y agoNo, I haven't. On the other hand, I don't think I've ever made a payment either way, and I'm not even sure that my bank account has the facility to do so. They're certainly no use for things like purchases in a typical online store.
- jivings 6y agoIn the EU we have Instant Payments powered by SEPA[1], which requires banks to confirm payment is sent/received in under 10 seconds. So yes, it's certainly available and possible, and incident of fraud is very low by all accounts. [1]: https://www.ecb.europa.eu/paym/integration/retail/instant_payments/html/index.en.html https://www.ecb.europa.eu/paym/integration/retail/instant_pa...