4 ms·
> [Free speech is] a fundamentally optimistic vision: Good ideas win. The better argument will prove persuasive. Wrong, wrong, wrong! Free speech is pessimisti
by zozbot234 6y ago
> [Free speech is] a fundamentally optimistic vision: Good ideas win. The better argument will prove persuasive.
Wrong, wrong, wrong! Free speech is pessimistic as heck. It's saying that good ideas don't necessarily win, but if you allow authoritarians to engage in arbitrary censorship then bad ideas will always win. Censoring free speech is not just a "crude authoritarian's" move; it's what all authoritarians do whenever they feel they can get away with it. And censorship won't save you from propaganda either: there's a lot of crude propaganda in every totalitarian regime, happily coexisting with censorship of every other point of view!
Free speech is NOT a problem: it's a very real safeguard against critical threats. If you treat it like one, you haven't seriously engaged with the issue.
- wisty 6y agoFree speech is a Monte Carlo method - it certainly delivers a probably good solution.
- UncleOxidant 6y agoBut there's no guarantee that it will. When people argue that free discourse will eventually always end up at the "best" place (whatever they define "best" to be) it almost sounds like some kind of appeal to a diety.
- crazygringo 6y agoWell, traditionally according to political philosophy, free speech is most associated with John Stuart Mill who did praise it out of optimism. That is the common understanding of it. I'm not sure what philosophical viewpoint you're referring to when you describe it as "pessimistic as heck". If you want to seriously engage with the issue, the article explores a lot of aspects of it, and why 100% unfettered free speech is potentially a problem to democracy.
- abecedarius 6y agoMill promoted free speech realistically as better than the alternative, is how I'd put it. Here's where he made his case; it's not too long to read: https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/On_Liberty/Chapter_2 https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/On_Liberty/Chapter_2
- jacquesm 6y agoBut he lived well before the age of the internet and maybe, you know, just maybe when the world changes we should adapt to it rather than to dogmatically hold that what one person thought a couple of hundred years ago should be enshrined and never ever be changed lest the sky falls down.
- amadeuspagel 6y agoMaybe, you know, just maybe we can learn something from people writing on timeless issues, even if they wrote before the lastest technological change.
- jacquesm 6y agoIn that case, let's make the bible our literal guide and get it over with. Of course you can learn something from people writing on timeless issues. But by making them the dogmatic truth you get locked in.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- abecedarius 6y agoI completely agree that citing authority is not an argument. I only contend here that the GP made an inaccurate summary in dismissing Mill's argument; and that argument is only one chapter, not the whole book as you might think from the way it's cited. You might find it pretty on point: he wrote in Victorian times which were also a local maximum of social pressure to profess the correct thoughts. Also a time with unprecedented new media (though I don't recall that topic coming up in this chapter).
- noxer 6y agoExactly, in fact it doesn't even matter what comes out of it there is simply no alternative to Free Speech that could work. Free Speech at least can work that's more than any other concept has to offer.
- gonational 6y agoEverything you said is 100% true. Anyone who tries to take this right, or any other right, away from you is planning to, in the long run, kill you. History tells us this very clearly.