8 ms·
Fighting for the right to repair your own stuff
- kerrsclyde 6y agoMy daughter smashed screen on her 4 year old Lenovo laptop, taking out panel and putting in new one took about 2mins. If I'd done same thing on my retina MBP you'd be looking at a serious repair, either by me or Apple (= $$$). Making me seriously consider where I'll buy my next laptop from.
- chrisseaton 6y agoAre you comparing an old-style low-def laptop panel against a modern retina one, though? Of course it'll be more expensive to replace and probably require a most specialised part.
- kwhitefoot 6y agoFair enough that the parts will be more costly but why should they be more difficult to replace?
- chrisseaton 6y agoThey're non-standard parts so may need non-standard connectors and mountings.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ab_testing 6y agoNo. A Full HD replacement screen for a last year's Lenovo Thinkpad can be had for as little as $59 on Amazon. https://www.amazon.com/BRIGHTFOCAL-Thinkpad-1920x1080-Replacement-Display/dp/B07ZNL8NNR/ref=sr_1_3_sspa?dchild=1&keywords=ThinkPad+T480&qid=1602957157&s=pc&sr=1-3-spons&psc=1&spLa=ZW5jcnlwdGVkUXVhbGlmaWVyPUFTUDFBN0RJR1I4TFImZW5jcnlwdGVkSWQ9QTAwODE4OTkzTU1YTjZXTVBXUUpOJmVuY3J5cHRlZEFkSWQ9QTAwNTQwNDkzR0I2M003Mjk0NThQJndpZGdldE5hbWU9c3BfYXRmJmFjdGlvbj1jbGlja1JlZGlyZWN0JmRvTm90TG9nQ2xpY2s9dHJ1ZQ== https://www.amazon.com/BRIGHTFOCAL-Thinkpad-1920x1080-Replac...
- chrisseaton 6y ago> No. A Full HD replacement screen for a last year's Lenovo Thinkpad can be had for as little as $59 on Amazon What are you saying no to? That's what I said - an old-style low-res Full HD screen is cheap and standard. A modern retina screen is not. That's why they're harder, and so more expensive, to replace.
- justinclift 6y agoIt's probably this bit: old-style low-def "Old style low-def" sounded more like the common super low-end 1280x768 panels. "Full HD" is at least reasonable, though people used to retina screens might not agree. ;)
- qz2 6y agoNot really. Swapping just the screen out on a Lenovo unit takes about 5 minutes with a screwdriver and spudger. It doesn't matter what screen you put in it really so I don't get this point. If they did a retina one that fits in the hole then it'd work. I have done this numerous times on older Thinkpads to put 1080p IPS screens in. On top of that the entire lid assembly is 500% less of a shit show than the MacBooks are (I have repaired several of them as well) for 2mm or so of extra thickness.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> If they did a retina one that fits in the hole then it'd work. Do they do that? That's the point. The Apple retina one is non-standard because it's more modern. That's why it's harder to replace. That's why it's more expensive to replace. > I have done this numerous times on older Thinkpads to put 1080p IPS screens in. Yes... I'm saying that's the easy one. The hard one is the modern retina MacBook.
- qz2 6y agoLook for 5D10V82348. 14" UHD. Just drops in.
- dehrmann 6y agoI've had several IBM and Lenovo Thinkpads, and even replaced a motherboard on one, and I agree that they're generally repairable, but the part is going to be $$. It gets better once the laptop is older and parts start showing up on eBay.
- qz2 6y agoYes. Retina MBP screen pop nearly cost me £450 a few years back. When the option was presented I bought a second hand Lenovo T470 for the same money and sold the broken MacBook Pro as is on ebay and took the kids out for a couple of days with the change. How did I break the screen? Well I dropped it three inches onto my sofa. Yes that fragile if you get it at the right angle. No thanks! I've had several thinkpads and nearly beaten them to death basically and they just keep going. I poured an entire cup of coffee in one a couple of years back and fell over with it while running and it had a cracked keyboard footprint which was replaced for £15 from ebay. It still worked fine when I sold it.
- Spivak 6y agoYeah, Apple’s fixation on tight manufacturing tolerances is absolutely nuts with their screens. They give them zero room to warp or bend so they just shatter. It was not fun when I had to manage a fleet of them. With around 200 laptops total we constantly had a stack of 10 rotating in/out of the Apple store for broken screens. The only thing worse is the fact that the duty cycle on the USB-C ports is so stupidly low. We ended up getting everyone these little port saver things because we got tired of sending laptops in for worn out ports.
- qz2 6y agoOh dont get me started on USB-C. My T470 has a broken USB-C after my wife tripped over the cable. Fortunately it has an old style thinkpad charger hole. My T495s has two USB-C ports which I'm hoping will last out the lifetime of the device. All are soldered directly to the motherboard :(
- kop316 6y agoThe past 3 phones I owned had to be replaced due to the USB-C port. I my current phone somehow doesn'tlike it and only charges with USB-C if I use a USB-A to USB-C. These are all Pixel phones.
- EdwinLarkin 6y agoThe right to repair is in my opinion a controversial topic. It basically boils down to costs of labor in western societies. Essentially it is too expensive to store parts, manuals and trained labor to repair products. It is way cheaper to just produce a new product from scratch.
- rvp-x 6y agoThe price threshold for repairing stuff in the west is simply a bit higher. Would you like to be limited to just the car shop that's certified by your car manufacturer for car repairs? I had a phone with a user-serviceable battery. It took no special parts to replace it. And so I used a machine that otherwise would've gone to electronic waste for several more years.
- orev 6y agoYour assessment is off the mark. The point of right to repair is for manufacturers to simply stop being hostile to repairing. Using screws with special/custom heads, forcing authentication of spare parts, etc., are all hostile. One could argue more about the use of glue in everything, but that’s more about the limitations of a specific design and not necessarily intentionally hostile (though in some cases it is). The cost of labor has absolutely nothing to do with this. A single person who wants to fix their own phone or tractor should be able to do it without having to jump through ridiculous hurdles or being outright blocked from doing so by the manufacturer.
- matz1 6y ago>The point of right to repair is for manufacturers to simply stop being hostile to repairing I'm all for right to repair that allow consumer freedom to repair their own device, i.e the manufacturer can't sue you for repairing your own device. What I won't support is if it require the manufacturer to design the product differently, i.e forcing apple to make thicker device/using different screw in order to make battery replaceable.
- genocidicbunny 6y ago
- inquirerofsorts 6y agoWhile I certainly align with the sentiment, it's almost surreal to watch in action. If you don't buy products with these conditions you never once face these problems. The title really should be: "fighting for the right to repair products I happily bought when the EULA clearly said I couldn't do that" Maybe stop buying these products and the companies will change their tune like the wind.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoYou mean the EULAs that no one ever reads because if they did, it would practically constitute a part-time job?
- msla 6y agoMore to the point, EULAs companies insist they can change at will and without notice, with your continued use of the service constituting your assent to the changed terms. The courts might say it doesn't work like that — again — but that's rather cold comfort when you're locked out of the system on Wednesday for something which was allowed on Monday: https://medium.com/@jlkoepke/we-can-change-these-terms-at-anytime-the-detritus-of-terms-of-service-agreements-712409e2d0f1 https://medium.com/@jlkoepke/we-can-change-these-terms-at-an... https://archive.vn/gwVci https://archive.vn/gwVci https://web.archive.org/web/20201017150508/https://medium.com/@jlkoepke/we-can-change-these-terms-at-anytime-the-detritus-of-terms-of-service-agreements-712409e2d0f1 https://web.archive.org/web/20201017150508/https://medium.co...
- jjoonathan 6y agoCollective-action solutions for collective action problems? Nah, let's just wait for everyone to simultaneously sacrifice for the greater good. Any day now... any day...
- rbecker 6y ago> If you don't buy products with these conditions you never once face these problems. Until they're the only kind of products left. See smart TVs.
- 6y ago
- sigmonsays 6y agothe farming right to repair case is a different case than phones/laptops case imo. farming tractors are much more expensive and much larger. You can't mail a tractor in a bubble-wrapped envelope. I support right to repair for farm equipment because its their job on the line. the mechanisms are much simpler in a tractor and mechanical in nature. trying to do the same with other appliances could be dangerous or fatal if mistakes are made. farmers are literally hacking their machines (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EPYy_g8NzmI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EPYy_g8NzmI ) likely voiding warranty.
- rhn_mk1 6y agoWhat's the influence of an item being small or possible to send on whether people should repair it? The mechanisms in a tractor are different, not necessarily simpler. Replacing a keyboard on a Thinkpad is both mechanical and as siple as it gets. Messing up a mechanical repair can absolutely be dangerous: it's a few horspower you could suddenly have out of control.
- jrace 6y agoMost farm implements are dangerous even when under normal operating conditions. Farmers must be self reliant and able to repair there equipment or else the farm can fail. And a failed farm can take years to come back - if ever.
- metalliqaz 6y agofound the apple employee the argument is nonsensical. size and expense should make no difference. if I purchase my product I own it, full stop. I can repair it if I want to.
- shagie 6y agoConsider the question of "something went wrong and the field was over-fertilized and will not be able to grow anything for 5 years" or "something went wrong and 5x the legal limit of pesticide was sprayed on the field." If this is stock equipment with stock software, the manufacture would be at least partly liable (probably fully liable). If you modify the equipment/software so that it plants seeds at a different density than the settings and inadvertently make it so that when the fertilizer runs it also overfertalizes the field - who is at fault? You own it. You can modify it. Is the manufacture still responsible for the functionality of the device after you modify it? If the modification is software and after the "oops, I screwed up" do a factory reset of the software - is the company properly able to defend itself from changes to the software?
- segmondy 6y agoOne of the best way to fight for right to repair is to avoid buying products that make it difficult to repair.
- rbecker 6y agoThat's a good idea, but not nearly enough. I haven't bought a single smart TV, but despite this, non-smart options have nearly disappeared from the consumer market. The only way to win this battle is through collective action in the form of legislation.
- tdsamardzhiev 6y agoNot sure this can be solved at personal level. I always put emphasis on repairability when buying tech, but my tech still gets less and less repairable every iteration.
- koski_pindora 6y agoJust a sidenote that to build stuff that is "also easy to be repaired" is not that easy. You need another new skilset from designers and mechanical designers to not only make small, beautiful and "easy to build and durable things" but also easy to fix things. You also need more from the production chain to be able to ship parts and instructions how to change them. And ship them. Things needs to be recyclable and should be fixable. Just saying, IMHO, that it is harder and I understand why in some stage it's not done.
- bluGill 6y agoTrue, but John deere makes a ton of money from selling spare parts. (despite what you hear, tractors are repairable) Deere Employee, but not speaking for my employer.
- lightwave25 6y agoBefore I read this article, I was thinking about how repair shops are making a come back. uBreakiFix has about 600 stores in the US that repair phones, tablets, computers, gaming systems and other devices every day.