3 ms·
Make it harder to generate garbage packets? BCP38 on the ISP side would solve IP spoofing and UDP reflection attacks. Stronger liability laws for both ISPs and
by Nextgrid 6y ago
Make it harder to generate garbage packets? BCP38 on the ISP side would solve IP spoofing and UDP reflection attacks. Stronger liability laws for both ISPs and end-users who deliberately expose vulnerable systems to the internet would help too.
- viraptor 6y ago2 issues: I mentioned Mirai which was not spoofed or reflected - just lots of devices and real sources. Garbage traffic as in something you didn't request. And the liability may work in one country, but you can't put a liability on ISPs internationally. Unless you want to end up in a situation where the US tells China their ISP is liable for spam traffic and hear that a US ISP is liable for traffic deemed illegal by the party. Anything but dumb pipes is going to be extremely complicated internationally.
- Nextgrid 6y ago> just lots of devices and real sources. Lots of devices deployed by someone, set up by someone, and someone is paying the internet bill for those devices to be online. Maybe the ISP should be talking to that someone, even in an automated way where vulnerability scanners cut off their access and they need to manually re-enable it after having disconnected the offending device? > US tells China their ISP is liable for spam traffic I think most countries would agree that certain behaviors are undesirable. The damage & waste of time caused by spam and malware transcends political and religious opinions for example. The solution doesn't have to be a legal liability per-se, simply a code of conduct that all ISPs agree to and anyone found to be in breach will get cut off by the others. They're not necessarily on the wrong side of the law, but for all intents and purposes their business is done because nobody will peer with them.
- viraptor 6y ago> cut off their access and they need to manually re-enable it after having disconnected the offending device? Sure. That's a possible meatspace solution and was used by some providers. It's not a protocol level solution though. > simply a code of conduct that all ISPs agree to and anyone found to be in breach will get cut off by the others Totally. Same thing could be applied to phone spam. It seems that nobody's that interested in it though.