3 ms·
> Saying "thank you" and giving credit to someone who did you a solid is pretty universally a norm. How much time have you spent looking for counterexamples in
by BeetleB 6y ago
> Saying "thank you" and giving credit to someone who did you a solid is pretty universally a norm.
How much time have you spent looking for counterexamples in the society where you live? Where people do something for the common good and most consumers do not say "Thank you". Have you done this exercise?
> Or, there's just the fraction of people who disregard and push back on norms
This is a convenient, self-fulfilling narrative. It is also pitting you into an adversarial position with someone. It's highly risky to insist on a norm and accuse others of not honoring it - and then be viewed as someone who is inflexible. It's your choice, though.
- mlyle 6y ago> How much time have you spent looking for counterexamples in the society where you live? I've spent a whole lot of time thinking about norms and observing their observance, enforcement, and what kinds of circumstances they tend to be disregarded. I've read a lot of the lit, too, thank you. > This is a convenient, self-fulfilling narrative. So is refusing to acknowledge the existence of norms because some people refuse to acknowledge them. Ultimately, our social reality is something we pretend into existence together. > It is also pitting you into an adversarial position with someone. It's highly risky to insist on a norm and accuse others of not honoring it - and then be viewed as someone who is inflexible. It's your choice, though. Whinging that someone broke norm A [e.g. seemed ungrateful] and thinking less of people/entities that you've heard have done the same is pretty cheap and isn't likely to earn you value judgments yourself.
- BeetleB 6y ago> I've spent a whole lot of time thinking about norms and observing their observance, enforcement, and what kinds of circumstances they tend to be disregarded. I've read a lot of the lit, too, thank you. Then I hope you've noticed that there are instances in society where "Saying thank you and giving credit to someone who did you a solid" is not the norm. > So is refusing to acknowledge the existence of norms because some people refuse to acknowledge them. We are in agreement here. > Whinging that someone broke norm A [e.g. seemed ungrateful] and thinking less of people/entities that you've heard have done the same is pretty cheap and isn't likely to earn you value judgments yourself. I have no idea what you're trying to say here. This sounds precisely what people are doing: Whining that Amazon seemed ungrateful and thinking less of people who do likewise. Which is orthogonal to what I'm saying.
- mlyle 6y ago> > > It's highly risky to insist on a norm and accuse others of not honoring it > This sounds precisely what people are doing: Whining that Amazon seemed ungrateful and thinking less of people who do likewise. Yup, and while there's variation in the hivemind, all in all I don't think a very large fraction of it is snapping back and thinking of the author as inflexible. So p'raps it's not so highly risky.