7 ms·
Remand is a crazy idea. Why do we detain people before they're proven guilty?
by chrisseaton 6y ago
Remand is a crazy idea. Why do we detain people before they're proven guilty?
- aaomidi 6y agoGovernments like that interest free cash.
- rhino369 6y agoFor serious crimes, because criminals would flee. For non-serious crimes we really shouldn't. But "cashless bail" has downsides. People are more likely to just skip hearings. Or they keep committing minor crimes because they don't view themselves as facing consequences.
- freeone3000 6y agoSkipping a hearing causes an arrest. It's not that you no longer have to show up, it's merely we'll take your word that you will (or we'll arrest you again) without requiring money up front.
- zepto 6y agoYou can’t so easily arrest someone who has taken flight, since you don’t know where they are. Police generally don’t have a lot of resources to track people down.
- freeone3000 6y agoblink That's... that's half their job. The vast majority of people who don't show up to court cases aren't criminal masterminds who have the resources to fly around the world, they're usually staying at their brother's or their cousin's. Or their own house. And you'd have to track the people down, deposit or not. The deposit doesn't change whether they show up.
- zepto 6y agoWhat deposit are you talking about? And.. staying with your cousin isn’t “taking flight” - it’s just being a fool. It doesn’t take a criminal mastermind to evade the police. They don’t keep searching indefinitely.
- freeone3000 6y agoThe deposit you leave at the courthouse that you get back when you attend trial.
- chrisseaton 6y agoWhat you're talking about is called a 'bail bond'.
- zepto 6y agoUnderstood. I wasn’t talking about bail bonds. I was talking about remand.
- freeone3000 6y agoSystems without cash bail still have remand. It's reasonable to deem someone to dangerous or flighty to release. It's cruel to demand a legalized bribe for release.
- zepto 6y agoFair point. I agree - this creates a 2 tier justice system.
- DenisM 6y ago> they keep committing minor crimes because they don't view themselves as facing consequences A speedy trial might help with that. And it's a great idea in any event.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> For serious crimes, because criminals would flee. That's a good reason for not going simple OR (own recognizance), and may in cases where there is more personal information beyond just a serious crime be part of why particular suspects ought not be considered for bail of any kind, but not a good reason, in any case, for a jail or cash-bail binary choice. > But "cashless bail" has downsides. People are more likely to just skip hearings. D.C. uses a no-cash-bail system, and IIRC does not see this compared to either when they used cash bail or to other jurisdictions that do. > Or they keep committing minor crimes because they don't view themselves as facing consequences. Again, I don't think there's evidence that this is the case, but insofar as it is, it seems it would be a speedy trial problem. (And/or a reason certain suspects ought not to be eligible for bail of any kind.)
- chrisseaton 6y ago> For serious crimes, because criminals would flee. Well if you weren't detaining them... 'fleeing' wouldn't be a thing so they couldn't flee and problem solved. As long as they turn up for their trial what's the problem? If they don't, prosecute them for that as well.
- loeg 6y agoTheoretically, two reasons: flight risk, and if you think the person is probably guilty, risk of re-offence. IMO flight risk isn't a real concern most of the time, and the modern surveillance state makes flight much more difficult than in ye olden days. I'm not keen on keeping suspects locked up on risk of re-offence, either; it seems a total violation of presumption of innocence.
- juniper_strong 6y ago>> I'm not keen on keeping suspects locked up on risk of re-offence, either; it seems a total violation of presumption of innocence So if you were making the laws, the trooper that pulled over Timothy McVeigh would have just given him a summons and told him to show up in court?
- cameldrv 6y agoWhen you say that flight risk isn't a real concern, something like 25% of people on bail fail to appear. Ultimately it often falls to bounty hunters to go find them. I agree that holding someone without a conviction looks like a violation of the presumption of innocence. This is why the right to a speedy trial is in the constitution, to minimize this violation. Unfortunately that right is somewhat theoretical. Depending on the crime, people spend on average between 50 and 200 days in jail before trial. This is way too long and we should really figure out how to streamline these processes for the cases where someone really does need to be held for trial.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> When you say that flight risk isn't a real concern, something like 25% of people on bail fail to appear. Well, it's certainly not a real concern that is addressed by cash bail; if someone is inclined to flee prosecution for a major crime, a cash bail will either (a) be unaffordable, and thus equivalent to no bail, or (b) affordable and an acceptable cost to sacrifice when fleeing. If you think about what people are fleeing if they are fleeing bail, it makes sense. Bail is essentially taking money. If someone can post a million dollars bail, but thinks they can evade the Justice system by fleeing, a million dollars probably isn't going to be worth a sizable risk of being imprisoned for whatever the potential sentence is for their crime. OTOH, non-cash-bail systems tend to put more focus on monitoring and related conditions which have a real and meaningful impact on flight.
- s5300 6y agoYou ever hear that thing where we don't hire people if they may be in debt for jobs that are said to matter or be a risk? Well, we have this thing called civil forfeiture... It lets you take somebody's money if you're a cop. So let's say you're a cop in need of some money. You can simply pull somebody over, among others things... and... take their money Well, what would you do if somebody just took your money? You might want to tell on them, or at least get your money back. Easiest way to not get told on with consequence if you stole somebody's money? Put them in jail with the powers vested in you...
- pessimizer 6y ago> Why do we detain people before they're proven guilty? There are a lot of reasons to do this. The real question is why the detention is designed to be punitive, and why can you pay to get out of it?
- russh 6y agoTo soften up those people up for the plea bargain phase of the american legal adventure.