3 ms·
This does show something interesting about how choice alters preference, but it doesn’t seem to generalize to the title at all. The experimental setup doesn’t
by zepto 6y ago
This does show something interesting about how choice alters preference, but it doesn’t seem to generalize to the title at all.
The experimental setup doesn’t have ecological validity as a model for babies typical environments.
The experimenters had to go out of their way to manufacture a situation in which the choice produced a random result.
This is a clever experiment that produces a useful result about choice strengthening preference.
It doesn’t however generalize into the idea that our preferences are a consequence of mere randomness.
1. In the absence of the contrived situation, choices will reflect the genetic predispositions of the baby, coupled with what is afforded by the environment.
2. If someone acts to create a contrived situation for the baby, then preferences will be systematically biased by that contrivance.
Neither of these are surprising statements, although the experiments results confirm (or can be deduced from) #2.
The random case doesn’t actually occur outside the laboratory, and if it did, it would be just a special case of #2.
So, “who we are is just a product of random choices we made as babies” is not a good interpretation of this result because babies actually don’t make random choices unless you put them in a special laboratory situation.