7 ms·
Neutral is very much in the eye of the beholder. To start considering this scenario, we'd have to ask "Who will be the arbiter of whether a site's content is 'n
by shadowgovt 6y ago
Neutral is very much in the eye of the beholder. To start considering this scenario, we'd have to ask "Who will be the arbiter of whether a site's content is 'neutral?'"
- kyleblarson 6y agoSeems like a pretty easy call if the site in question blocks peoples' accounts for posting an article from the 4th largest print news publication in the USA.
- mthoms 6y agoIt's only "a pretty easy call" when you cherry pick extremely easy, outlying examples. What about more nuanced cases? Who will be arbiter of "neutral" then?
- bananabreakfast 6y agoIt was an article that blatantly violated the posting medium's terms. Doesn't matter if the government itself posted that article. Doxxing info is immoral and should be blocked.
- eranimo 6y agoIt's actually the 8th largest, not 4th largest.
- joshuaheard 6y agoFollow the First Amendment.
- kodablah 6y agoBut the first amendment prevents the government from telling me or my company that I have to follow the first amendment like they do.
- roywiggins 6y agoPrecisely. Enforcing "neutrality" on private parties would be unconstitutional viewpoint discrimination.
- eli 6y agoThe First Amendment is in conflict with the government regulating what viewpoints companies allow on their platforms.
- joshuaheard 6y agoSection 230 does that now. It gives platforms publisher immunity. They could change the law to require platforms to follow the first amendment in order to retain their publisher immunity.
- shadowgovt 6y agoThey could. "Should they" is a very reasonable question. I, for one, appreciate the current status quo where I generally don't have to deal with neo-Nazis spouting nonsense uncontested on my Facebook wall (and if that arrangement bothers me, I could go to some other site).
- joshuaheard 6y agoYou can block that or contest it, as you wish. I've been called a Nazi for opposing critical race theory. Where do you draw the line? Social media companies lean left, the government should ensure they remain neutral by following the First Amendment.
- shadowgovt 6y ago> You can block that or contest it, as you wish. I'm happy to do so. I'm also happy the platform has some base-level standards so I don't have to block and contest quite so much. > Social media companies lean left, the government should ensure they remain neutral by following the First Amendment. Is there anything in particular about social media, as a technology, that causes all companies engaging in it to "lean left?" If not, this is a problem the market can solve.