2 ms·
>I see long threads on HN all the time of brilliant people convinced that supply and demand is just "far too simple" or "totally disproved" etc. etc. Then ther
by pydry 6y ago
>I see long threads on HN all the time of brilliant people convinced that supply and demand is just "far too simple" or "totally disproved" etc. etc.
Then there are those who think econ 101 has all the answers.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Veblen_good https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Veblen_good
If they taught physics they wouldn't be teaching us the law of gravity. They'd be teaching us the law of "what goes up must come down".
- bgorman 6y agoBasic microeconomics teaches that demand is a schedule of what customers are willing to pay at various price points, and that businesses need to apply "marginal" analysis aka calculus to optimize profit. There is nothing about the basic building blocks of microeconomics that makes it incompatible for the analysis of luxury products. Most product are not luxury products and a large portion of the world lives in poverty, so naturally most Econ 101 discussions of microeconomics will deal with commodity products e.g. bread. Like anything worth learning, it is far more important to understand the basic principles of the subject than to learn details about specific applications. That is memorization over understanding.
- 8ytecoder 6y agoMarket alone is almost never the solution. I know an angel investor living in a rent controlled apartment in the most desirable neighbourhood in SF. Put a cap on income for rent control. Allow market to function. Any property that follows planning rules, is in the right zone and follows rules for low income/below market rate housing, allow it to be built without delay. Fix stupid zoning laws that make building anything over two stories illegal in a huge swath of the city. (An example is using tradeable floor space index to regulate zones instead of fixed height based codes) You can do all of this and build public transit options to keep the quality of life stable. It’s possible. It requires will to execute and a multi year or even multi decade plan.
- sumtechguy 6y agoThere are 2 curves in any market. The demand curve and the supply curve. The supply curve is usually fairly easy to figure out (borderline trivial). The demand curve on the other hand does very odd things and tries to measure things there is no measurement for. Even economies where there is no real price and there is only a monopoly has to conform to the two curves. Most economic policies fail because of poor forecasting of external items on changes in the demand curve. For example maybe I had an egg for breakfast and that made me feel full for lunch. So I do not want to eat a hamburger at any price for the rest of the week. Yet the demand curve would predict I would buy it at a particular price. Economics a lot of hand wavy predictions. It is good at saying what happened after the fact but usually makes poor predictions. Most sciences would say the model is broken. The Veblen good that you mention is one of those examples. Where raising the price creates a desirability that should not be there. That is because pricing is a signal of scarcity. Some people desire the idea they have something scarce and others dont. Which makes demand curves hard as even the price you pick changes the curve!