2 ms·
1950 was also the point when: * Auto manufacturers consolidated to 3 big companies and started to more consistently put smaller startup automakers out of busin
by pydry 6y ago
1950 was also the point when:
* Auto manufacturers consolidated to 3 big companies and started to more consistently put smaller startup automakers out of business.
* They got into protracted fights with unionizing workers.
* They stopped building manufacturing plants in detroit itself and built them further afield to cut labor and land costs.
I think we can see these trends being mirrored in the tech industry right now.
- redisman 6y agoMaybe 1.5 or 2 out of 3, but > unionizing workers does not sound like SV today. You're also missing the main reason, superior products from Japan and Germany. We don't really see that as of now. China and EU have a handful of competitive companies.
- option 6y agoplease, what kind of competitive advantage EU has in tech? Sure, China has some advantages but it also has huge disadvantages as well.
- jdminhbg 6y agoI think you misread the parent. They're saying the EU and China only have a handful of companies competitive with the SV giants.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- inglor_cz 6y agoToday no, but the gig economy is probably not sustainable without some pushback. So, not core tech workers, but the worker bees at Amazon ... ?
- normaljoe 6y agoIt's not that SV is union workers but that union workers have a higher labor cost. Kind of goes to why GM started Saturn in TN and why Saturn cars where cheap in the late 80s, no unions thus cheaper labor. SV labor is expensive compared to other markets (see below). I have worked in SV and elsewhere and mostly elsewhere is 1/2 the pay as SV and without the things like free lunch / coffee bar / shuttle service. SV doesn't need unions because the turnover rate is so high that the companies are basically providing what unions would negotiate just to compete (free lunch / coffee bar / shuttle service). It's still a buyers market from the employee standpoint. I do think SV is not quite at the inflection point just yet, but it is moving in that direction. The irony in this is actually that the cost of labor is high because the cost of living is high. The cost of living is high because of the NIMBY folks preventing multiunit housing. If the ballon collapses those NIMBY folks would see their precious house values decline. Finally as to superior products most Japanese and German cars sold in the US are still built in the US, just not Detroit because of.... Wait for it.... Union Workers.
- krschultz 6y agoEvery major tech company is grappling with the balance between their leadership and employee base right now. It may not look exactly like the UAW in Detroit, but that tension definitely echos into our time. It's quite a bit different than 5-10 years ago.
- nostrademons 6y agoFord and GM date from 1903 and 1908, respectively. Chrysler from 1925. There were plenty of other car makers (Packard, Studebaker, Duesenberg, AMC, Hudson, etc.), but most of them were started in the 1910s-1920s and then went defunct in the 1950s. There are plenty of other Silicon Valley tech companies (Stripe, AirBnB, Uber, Lyft, Dropbox, Coinbase, Roblox, etc.), and many of them are just starting their growth curve.
- Nasrudith 6y ago* They stopped building manufacturing plants in detroit itself and built them further afield to cut labor and land costs. That is an antonym of the Silicon Valley situation - they tried numerous times to outsource and move to cheaper locations and failed. The closest to success were San Fransico and Palo Alto which effectively just sprawled the area that is effectively Silicon Valley outside the prior bounds. The attempts to go far afield failed and the physical manufacturing wasn't where the money was located resulting in a minor shake up. There is a historical resemblance superficially in the first point but the second two are outright foils as every little highly publicized kerfluffle for what is effectively a relatively fringe cause like say not taking DoD contracts is nothing compared to a work stop or a gain of union claim to control. Come to think of it the employee stock share benefits are a sort of weird foil to a union - not even trying for control or working conditions but giving some token stake to sufficiently valued workers. Not a replacement by any means but it is an ironic undermining of a company vs worker mentality.
- cafard 6y agoThe big unionizing fights happened in the 1930s, didn't they?