3 ms·
> At every step Visa and MasterCard promotes highest possible level of security. No doubt you've drunk the Kool-Aid but this isn't true. EMV rests heavily upon
by tialaramex 6y ago
> At every step Visa and MasterCard promotes highest possible level of security.
No doubt you've drunk the Kool-Aid but this isn't true. EMV rests heavily upon cryptographic protocols, we know the highest possible level of security is achieved for such protocols by publishing them for evaluation and improvement by independent researchers. EMV didn't do that.
There are many but here's a particularly low hanging piece of fruit that results from not having independent researchers looking over what you've done:
It is critical to the EMV design that the payment terminal picks unpredictable numbers. These aren't just nonces, where it only matters that they're different, they must be random or a relatively cheap (worth doing to forge credit card transactions) attack succeeds. So what do you suppose those standards documents require? You might even have read it.
The certification document says for testing read two of these "unpredictable" values. Ensure they are different.
Guess what lots of real hardware actually deployed in the wild does to achieve that requirement? It uses a counter. Because random numbers might sometimes not be different leading to a tiny chance of failing the mandatory test, but a counter will reliably pass the test even though it's insecure. Genius. So you go from "Hypothetical adversary needs to guess a large random number" to "It's just a counter" and attack cost falls from billions of dollars to a few cents per transaction on top of R&D.