6 ms·
Regarding 2: I would love to see some of the community aspects of christianity/religion brought back in a secular form. It seems like believing in God isn't rea
by nicoburns 6y ago
Regarding 2: I would love to see some of the community aspects of christianity/religion brought back in a secular form. It seems like believing in God isn't really the key part. It's interacting with your neighbours, which seems to be something really missing from a lot of the western world over the last few decades.
- keiferski 6y agoFor sure, and I think that's a widespread political problem too. I wonder if online hostility and polarization would be reduced if people simply had calm in-person discussions with each other once a week. Social media is optimized for outrage and offensiveness.
- bilbo0s 6y ago"I wonder if online hostility and polarization would be reduced if people simply had calm in-person discussions with each other once a week" That might work for some people? I don't know? But I do know that the Charleston church shooter sat down with a bunch of little old ladies for the duration of a bible study engaging in, what I can only assume was, a calm in-person discussion. Then he blew their heads off. Point is that, for some reason, the internet has a much stronger hold over people than do in person connections. People deeply believe they are more connected to people in their virtual spaces than they are to their neighbors or even physical friends. That sense of connection is real to those people. To some of those people, it's real enough to kill for.
- wool_gather 6y agoThat's not really a good counterexample. Do you think that Roof attended the bible study with the intent of actually discussing -- let alone listening to -- anything? It was almost without question just part of the setup for his attack.
- leetcrew 6y agoI think you are arguing from outliers here. contrary to how it may seem on the news, mass shootings are quite rare events, even in the US. the fact that you and I have registered accounts and made at least one post on HN makes us outliers even in this community. are there some people for whom virtual spaces are more real than their neighbors and IRL friends? sure, but most people don't seem to be like that. as far as I can tell, most people use social media to interact with an extended network of IRL friends/family. some people do try to get tons of followers that they don't know on instagram, but I think even this is best understood as jockeying for status among IRL peers. note: IRL is a somewhat antiquated term this days, but I use it as a shorthand for "relationships that originate in in-person interactions". so if I had a friend A who moved away and befriended B there, but we all play video games together, B is still an IRL friend to me.
- Pfhreak 6y agoI've seen this in a lot of socialist circles -- an emphasis on building resilient communities, supporting your neighbors and fellow workers, and trying to lift everyone up. I expect that there will be a strong reaction on this forum to the word 'socialist', but the communities you describe definitely still exist.
- nicoburns 6y ago> the communities you describe definitely still exist I agree that they do exist. But they don't seem to be mainstream as they once were, and I'd very much like to change that.
- Pfhreak 6y agoMe too! Join the DSA! :D But also, historically, these sorts of communities have been targeted by governments. Police literally went to war with unions to break up community power for coal miners. While communism is different than socialism, there's a huge public smear campaign trying to couple those two together. (And, in fact, historically there were major pushes to blacklist folks who were connected to communism.)
- jpttsn 6y agoBut how would this idea work on a national scale?
- bittercynic 6y agoUse popular media to normalize inviting your neighbors round for a bbq, asking your handy neighbor for help when you have a plumbing problem, regularly say hello and sometimes have a chat/catch up with neighbors to maintain lines of communication to make the above possible.
- tartoran 6y agoBasically using popular media to make people interact more IRL, suggest people consume less and basically de-throne media goes against the aligned incentives of the whole system and its success. Did we paint ourselves into a corner? Ok, the paint will dry eventually but it might be a completely different color from when it was wet.
- seneca 6y agoBelieving in God is not the key part, but believing in some unifying idea is necessary. People are extremely tribal. You need something that defines an "Us" for people the rally around.
- dageshi 6y agoI think you would need some kind of semi-strong central anchor, like religion to make this happen. And I don't really know if that exists anymore on a local geographic level.
- Kluny 6y agoYes - CS Lewis pointed out the value of going to church in your local parish rather than shopping around for a church that suits you. Instead of having your beliefs reinforced by people who are like you, they are influenced by the people who happen to live near you. Those people may be more diverse in age, wealth and nationality than your other friends, but they are linked to you by a shared interest in your neighbourhood. This builds community and helps open minds.
- johnrob 6y agoHe’s basically suggesting the exact opposite of the social media news feed, which we’ve proved to be hazardous.
- claudeganon 6y ago> This builds community and helps open minds. As someone who grew up in a small, rural Christian community, this is a nice sentiment, but far from true in my experience. People instead become highly punitive and disparaging towards anyone who does not think and behave exactly like them. Whatever community exists is built around a hateful exclusion of “the other.”
- Kluny 6y agoIt certainly can go that way, yes.
- 3np 6y agoI by no means want to invalidate your experience, but from someone else who also grew up in a rural Christian (European Lutheran) community, I can’t recall churchgoers talking or caring much about each other’s beliefs - there was the whole range from secularists who were in it for the local community through devout fundamentalists and AFAIK (left as a teenager so it’s possible I missed things) it was never an issue. That being said, there was definitely a “fear of the other “ with people being extremely suspicious of the few handful of outsiders who moved in and didn’t have any connection like relatives, existing connections, or children going to school there.
- brobdingnagians 6y agoI think the shared belief, sense of purpose, and sense of something greater beyond this life _is_ a key to it. I don't think secularism can provide a strong enough motivation channeled into something productive. It can evoke strong emotion, but it usually ends with days of rage and such. Religion and belief in deity has pretty much always provided that (and even then there are lots of examples of that not working). I don't think we are going to buck the lessons of thousands of years of human history and find some kind of "enlightened secularism" that hasn't worked before.
- bluetomcat 6y agoI think the postmodern intellectual narratives are breaking it all in the West. The denial of objective truth, the rise of moral relativism, the notions about expressing the individual via many group identities, etc. It's a demoralizing view of life that is far-reaching in our contemporary culture. Even if you look at architecture, design and urban planning, you can find bits of that "wisdom" everywhere.
- agent008t 6y agoIn addition, there is no positive vision of the future for society as a whole. What does the US look like in 2075 or 2100? All we get are dystopias. I get that the World, and Europe in particular, got badly burnt by Utopias in the 20th century. But still seems like something is needed - especially given the looming geopolitical changes.
- xxpor 6y agoHow is this not an argument that the masses are too stupid to handle themselves and need to be brainwashed for social control and stability? That's essentially what religion is, especially Abrahamic religions based on nothing but completely made up stories.
- jazzyjackson 6y agoWe're talking about purpose, not control. It seems true to me that most individuals (myself included) are not up to the task of inventing a reason to exist. You can moan about how the stories are made up til Kingdom come, the point of it is practicing the belief. Otherwise you get what we're talking about in this thread, billions of people growing up believing nothing, having no rational reason to believe they are valuable, no reason to think the future warrants their contribution.
- Balgair 6y agoFortunately, there already exists a secular church, so to speak: Unitarian Universalism[0]. The modern Unitarian Universalist (UU) church is very welcoming to people of all faiths, religions, and creeds. You do not need to be atheist to join, nor do you need to believe in anything. Most congregations are very welcoming of new members. Four US Presidents, eleven Nobel prize winners, and Sir Tim Berners-Lee are Unitarians. There are many Unitarians out there, though they do not tend to proselytize much, which is maybe why you haven't heard of them. As always, finding the right congregation is very important. The UU church has a good site here to help: https://www.uua.org/find https://www.uua.org/find With the current Covid-19 crisis, local churches near you may be closed or only doing virtual services. Please check with the minister. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unitarianism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unitarianism
- rhn_mk1 6y agoThe actual Wikipedia link is: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unitarian_Universalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unitarian_Universalism
- Balgair 6y agoSorry! Thanks for the catch!
- Der_Einzige 6y agoI attended my local UU church extensively as an atheist for awhile. 10/10 would recommend.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoThey are good people and a good community. I had a similar experience as an agnostic and was welcomed with open arms into their community. I move from that town a while back but still keep in touch with some of the members. Completely different experience than the close minded, judgemental,self possessed, obsessive evangelicals that I grew up around.
- 6y ago
- Gys 6y ago> It seems like believing in God isn't really the key part. Maybe that is why the devil and the hell were introduced at some point ;-) Edited: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Augustinian_theodicy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Augustinian_theodicy
- chriswarbo 6y ago> Regarding 2: I would love to see some of the community aspects of christianity/religion brought back in a secular form. You're essentially describing (secular) Humanism, e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secular_humanism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secular_humanism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Humanists_UK https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Humanists_UK https://humanism.org.uk/civi/humanism/local https://humanism.org.uk/civi/humanism/local
- BeetleB 6y agoI don't have the actual study at hand, but it's cited in the book "The Righteous Mind".[1] They looked at independent communes[2] in the US in the 1800's, and 20 years after the founding of a commune, 6% of the secular ones were still around, as opposed to 39% of the religious ones. The latter had more things binding them. One insight: In religious communes, sacrifices (no alcohol, etc) correlated with longevity. In secular communities, there was no correlation. Over there, every sacrifice had to be argued about and justified. There was less thrash in religious communes. (Just found the author of the study/studies: Sosis[3] [1]: https://www.amazon.com/Righteous-Mind-Divided-Politics-Religion/dp/0307455777/ref=sr_1_1 https://www.amazon.com/Righteous-Mind-Divided-Politics-Relig... [2]: A commune being defined as a group of people not sharing kinship deciding to live and work together. [3]: https://anthropology.uconn.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/944/2018/06/2003-Sosis-Cooperation-and-commune-longevity.pdf https://anthropology.uconn.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/944/...