2 ms·
So you're saying the only courtesies we should render to others in life are ones that we're duty-bound by license agreements or other contracts to give? Out wi
by mlyle 6y ago
So you're saying the only courtesies we should render to others in life are ones that we're duty-bound by license agreements or other contracts to give?
Out with social norms and niceties, and in with black letter law?
I don't want to legally demand a specific acknowledgement; I know that this can have unintended consequences and greatly complicates adoption.
Also: If my stuff is used at the periphery of something you're doing, I don't really care. On the other hand, if you get to market by largely just repackaging what I've made, it seems that by social norms I'm due a hat tip, whether or not it's legally demanded.
- meddlepal 6y ago> So you're saying the only courtesies we should render to others in life are ones that we're duty-bound by license agreements or other contracts to give? Nothing you do for your employer as part of work should be considered "courtesy" or a "social nicety".
- mlyle 6y agoThe "something you do for your employer as part of work" was a strawman and doesn't relate to what we're talking about. We're talking about whether it meets social norms to take open source work, launch it as the core piece of a product, and do the absolute minimum legally required acknowledgment.
- LocalH 6y agoI think they’re bemoaning the fact that many employers will couch it in terms of courtesy yet also claim the right to be angry if you don’t go above what is required. It should be encouraged to do more than required, yes. But it shouldn’t be punishable if you don’t.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- craftinator 6y agoYeah, as long as my company will double my pay when I ask for it as a courtesy, I'll come in on my days off as a courtesy. Tit tat
- mlyle 6y agoThe employer thing is a strawman here; the subject of the article is AWS forking and launching a product with minimal (but legal) attribution. I didn't argue -anything- about the employer case, staying on topic to AWS's behavior.
- didibus 6y ago> So you're saying the only courtesies we should render to others in life are ones that we're duty-bound by license agreements or other contracts to give? Isn't that the whole point behind the rule of law and the civil society? Anything that isn't well understood or known in advance of someone engaging in an activity, and then later faces unfair retribution because apparently they didn't do what wasn't told to them that needed be done, or did something that wasn't told to them shouldn't be done. All these "social norm" sounds like guilt trip and power grabs to me. You did something you said was free and that you were giving it to me no string attached, then you come back and guilt trip me saying that there were in fact strings attached and that you expected things in return. Now, yes I understand that maybe when you said hey this is open source with Apache license, you had in mind an audience of students, or one man startups, or hobbyist, or amateurs, and hadn't really thought if it applied to big corps. And I actually wonder how the courts normally handle this, when someone who put the conditions forward first was in a position where they couldn't have anticipated the event and thus couldn't have pre-conditioned it. I'm not too sure how to handle it myself, but here I'm guessing is a lesson to learn for others, choose your license carefully, think about the various possibility.
- mlyle 6y ago> Anything that isn't well understood or known in advance of someone engaging in an activity, and then later faces unfair retribution because apparently they didn't do what wasn't told to them that needed be done, or did something that wasn't told to them shouldn't be done. Your argument self-contradicts. You assert, broadly, if it's legal it's OK. The "unfair retribution" of people getting annoyed about it and complaining is also legal, so that should be OK, too. :P > Now, yes I understand that maybe when you said hey this is open source with Apache license, you had in mind an audience of students, or one man startups, or hobbyist, or amateurs, and hadn't really thought if it applied to big corps. Nah, when I said "Apache License", I meant that legal license. But that doesn't mean doing some things that effectively cost nothing, that exceed the license requirements, aren't socially customary. There's no law that says you have to say "thank you" when someone renders you a service or has made something that makes your life easier or lets you make a bunch of money, but if you stand on legal grounds to avoid saying "thanks" you might be a dick, and people might call you out for being a dick.