3 ms·
I don't understand from the article how they knew the baby's initial choice was random. What if the baby originally selected that toy because they preferred it?
by Wowfunhappy 6y ago
I don't understand from the article how they knew the baby's initial choice was random. What if the baby originally selected that toy because they preferred it?
They could be drawn to the toy's color, or shape, or any number of other things.
- AlanYx 6y agoI wonder if there's an aspect of the experimental design that's left out of the linked article. For example, could the toys have been hidden behind some sort of shield, so that the baby couldn't see what color they were picking until they got to the shield? Otherwise, there doesn't seem to be any basis for concluding that the initial choice was random.
- User23 6y agoIndividual adult humans are terrible at producing randomness. Why would babies be any different?
- teraflop 6y agoThe actual paper (https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0956797620954491 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/095679762095449...) does mention this, even though the press release doesn't: > Specifically, we found that after selecting from two equally attractive objects, infants subsequently devalued the initially unchosen object. We ruled out the possibility that this reflects a desire for novelty or any intrinsic preference among the options. The experimental design that allowed them to do this is simple, but pretty clever. The original version of the experiment is based on first letting the baby choose between toys A and B, and then demonstrating that if A was chosen, the baby prefers a new toy C over B. (All of the toys were equally likely to be preferred by a control group.) Since it's not possible to know whether the initial choice was random or based on individual preference, they did a modified version of this experiment. After the baby is shown the first two toys, they are placed under boxes and secretly swapped. Despite originally having chosen B, the baby instead gets to interact with A. In this case, the babies still fairly consistently choose C (the new toy) over B (the one they originally preferred but didn't get to interact with). And as the press release does mention, simply giving a baby a toy randomly chosen by the experimenter doesn't cause the same effect. So the reasonable inference is that the actual experience of making a choice (or at least having the illusion of doing so) reduces one's attachment to the option that wasn't chosen.
- AlanYx 6y agoThe actual paper is behind a paywall for me. I'm having trouble understanding your description of the experiment. How does selecting C over B, after initially preferring B, support the thesis that random choices become preferences? Shouldn't the baby select B over C to support that thesis?
- dllthomas 6y agoIIUC... The idea is that the baby selected the box they believed contained B, but it actually contained A. Apparently the baby concluded that since they had opened the box that they chose, they must have chosen the toy inside, and they now like A better and B worse.
- dllthomas 6y agoIf the secret swapping wasn't as secret as the experimenters thought, these results seem consistent with the babies having a stable, random preference order among the blocks. Otherwise, it does seem like they've demonstrated (something like?) choice induced preference change in babies, and it's additionally interesting that it can be tricked that way.
- gowld 6y agoNo, because the boxes were swapped after the initial preference selection.
- dllthomas 6y agoI don't understand.
- WalterSear 6y agoWhichever the baby chose, that became A, the other became B.
- 6y ago
- eperfa 6y ago"In follow-up experiments, when the researchers instead chose which toy the baby would play with, the phenomenon disappeared entirely. If you take the element of choice away, Feigenson said, the phenomenon goes away." (from the article)