2 ms·
What in my comment makes you say that?
by throwaway0a5e 6y ago
What in my comment makes you say that?
- watwut 6y ago> 1984 is a cautionary tale about communism but it applies to authoritarianism in general. A very left leaning state is simply going to have less people equipped to teach this lesson well than a right leaning state. It's really, really hard to do a good job teaching something that is ideologically uncomfortable. This thing. There is nothing ideologically uncomfortable about 1984 for pretty much anyone in both NYC suburbs and Virginia.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>This thing. There is nothing ideologically uncomfortable about 1984 for pretty much anyone in both NYC suburbs and Virginia. You don't think a pool of people (mostly) from a big government state that's been big government for a long time (in retrospect I should have picked Boston as it's a far better example) are gonna have a harder time teaching about the dangers of the extremes of big government than a pool of people who's ancestors are known for untaxed booze and trying to leave the union? You don't think that when the (hypothetical average) teacher tries to provoke class discussion by asking about modern implications the teacher who grew up in the latter culture might be a little bit better at provoking a good discussion?
- watwut 6y agoNo I dont, because I read that book and also know what American liberals talk about. You are strawmanning both. For that matter, you are making Virginians into caricature and you are almost mocking American revolution.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoI thought I made it clear clear that I am talking about differences at the margin.
- watwut 6y agoNo you did not. At the margin, considering that Orwell was commited socialist, left has marginally better chance to interpret him right - but this take would be wrong too.
- mcv 6y agoI think if the book is uncomfortable to teach for anyone in the US, it would be someone who believes in the need for Fox News-type propaganda. The book isn't merely about a government that runs schools, police, housing and that sort of stuff, it's about being told what to believe, even when it flies in the face of reality. Imagine a world where more people (are forced to) believe everything Trump says.