3 ms·
> A social platform that makes information more accessible to people is a threat to democracy? The problem is that the platform does not make all information a
by Nextgrid 6y ago
> A social platform that makes information more accessible to people is a threat to democracy?
The problem is that the platform does not make all information available equally. Instead, it uses algorithms to prioritize displaying certain information over the other (sometimes in direct contradiction with the user's wishes, where their friend's posts are ranked lower in the feed in favour of some unrelated bullshit).
Ultimately the problem is not just Facebook but the whole business model of advertising and engagement. Now this normally wouldn't be that big of a deal if people were aware of it and alternatives existed, but people seem to be oblivious to it (and the mismatch between their interests and Facebook's) and network effects make starting an alternative impossible (plus Facebook would abuse copyright laws to shut down any alternative services that would interoperate with them).
- haffi112 6y agoHow do you solve the problem of displaying information equally? There is already so much noise out there anyway; Facebook recognized the need for a filter like a newsfeed. Facebook is incentivized to keep people on their platform and, therefore, the filter is not designed for the end-user. But that is still Facebook playing by the rules. If enough people are not happy with that, then they should switch to another platform with a better filter.
- the_snooze 6y ago>Facebook recognized the need for a filter like a newsfeed. Typical Facebook: there's a problem of their own making and try to solve it by introducing more Facebook. I think Facebook is rotten because they keep dancing around the root of their problems: scale. If Facebook were to scale down connections by increasing the friction between people and groups so that individuals were nudged into interacting nearly exclusively with real-world personal contacts, then there would be little need for a technical filter. People's own social filters would take care of that for them. But you're right. That would be against Facebook's financial incentives because that would make them less valuable to advertisers. They wouldn't have the power to move audiences anymore if the audience is moving itself.
- Nextgrid 6y ago> There is already so much noise out there anyway Discourage the production of noise, or don't include it in the user's newsfeed unless he explicitly followed that source? Keep in mind that most "noise" and clickbait is produced because it is itself funded by advertising and "engagement". Have some rules that ban publicly posting clickbait or any kind of commercial, for-profit content (that will not be an issue for a network that supposedly wants to connect you with your friends), enforce them and watch the problem disappear by itself. Keep in mind that a large chunk of the content being posted on Facebook with total impunity would've quickly earned you a ban on most forums back in the day and this is how those forums kept spam, hate & off-topic content at bay during their existence and nobody made a big deal out of it. The problem is that obviously Facebook will not do that, not because of any kind of moral/ethical concerns about "free speech" or anything but because clickbait being around keeps the people spending more time on Facebook, generating more revenue for Facebook. The algorithm recognizes that and will keep giving more of such content to the user since it's continuously being rewarded with the resulting engagement. Forcing Facebook to change its rules by law could work but is impractical, but a better solution would be to change the law so that while the current Facebook rules are legal per-se, the consequences of those (and the content they allow people to post) would hold Facebook liable (any illegal post automatically considers Facebook as an accomplice of the underlying crime, whether it's scams, drug deals/resale of stolen property or hate speech). This would quickly force Facebook to clean up their act and discourage their users from posting such content.
- 542354234235 6y ago> this normally wouldn't be that big of a deal if people were aware of it and alternatives existed I would disagree with this. What makes it so dangerous is using big data and algorithmically driven “improvements” in time on site and engagement is exploiting subconscious weaknesses in our brains to do this. You can design an optical illusion to trick our visual perceptions to the point that even with we know for a fact what is happening, we can’t “fix” our perception in our brain. Imagine if you built an entire interactive space of optical illusions that were iterated and improved millions of times over so that a person was physically incapable of determining accurate visual data about the world around them. This is what is happening in our digital spaces. It is becoming physically harder and harder to disengage from those digital spaces, not because of individual moral failings, but because our reward centers are being continually bombarded by illusions that warp our perception.