2 ms·
> 18F or whatever publishes a lot of stuff like this. Markdown policy documents. I think it’s profoundly wasteful I think you’re under-estimating the value of
by pbronez 6y ago
> 18F or whatever publishes a lot of stuff like this. Markdown policy documents. I think it’s profoundly wasteful
I think you’re under-estimating the value of publishing a good policy from a respectable source within the Federal government.
Many of the government’s technology problems are actually self-inflicted policy problems. Publishing a good policy gives internal reformers a place to start. When the lawyers and security people start telling you no, it’s much more effective to say “actually this language comes directly from GSA, who approved it for X, which has the same compliance requirement you’re concerned about” than to simply protest that it’s industry best practice.
I do agree that this lawyers-first way of doing things kinda sucks. It’s certainly not the way to maximize tech success. But it’s the system/culture we’ve got. I’d love to hear ideas for changing it, especially if you can figure out a way to accomplish the privacy, security, integrity, and fairness objectives that the current system prioritizes.
A government agency struggling to serve the public good because it’s hobbled by obsolete tech is better than an agency enabled by cutting edge tech unshackled from the public interest and democratic legitimacy.
- an_opabinia 6y ago> But it’s the system/culture we’ve got. We wind up with a lot of political and business family dynasties despite the terrible incompetence of sons and daughters. Part of that is that families can operate totally without policies, that they are having horrible dynasty lawsuits because nothing is written on paper or litigated that way. Yet as long as they don’t sue each other, the lack of policy friction - a “liquidity” that may not show up as a dollar amount but as something else - makes the family dynasty surprisingly competitive. Wouldn’t it be ironic that policies - specifically the hundred+ page markdown output kind of policies, not something succinct like I don’t know, the Ten Commandments or the Bill of Rights - make the corrupt family dynasty more competitive?