3 ms·
Kilogram prototypes have all changed to different weights and no-one knows why
- rorrr 16y agoIt's an article on physorg.com that was copied from USA Today that doesn't specify the source of that information. My guess is that it will turn out to be a bullshit story or a measurement error.
- kragen 16y agoNo, this has been an issue for years. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kilogram#Stability_of_the_international_prototype_kilogram http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kilogram#Stability_of_the_inter...
- ElliotH 16y agoCalling the Planck constant 'esoteric' seems odd even if expressing it in total layman's terms could be difficult. I don't see why explaining that it's a constant relating to photons, light and energy would be too difficult, or too far away from the level the article is pitched at.
- spc476 16y agoAnd here I thought that the gram was defined by one cubic centimeter of pure water at 4°C.
- kragen 16y agoThat was the idea, but they immediately made a prototype kilogram mass in 1799 when they came up with that definition, and it turns out that it was off by about 25 ppm, and we've been working from that prototype ever since — so water only has that density to four significant figures.
- sorbus 16y agoHuh. I always thought that metric units of mass were defined by the mass of a mole of whatever atom you were interested in: a mole of carbon masses exactly 12 grams, a mole of oxygen masses 16 grams, a mole of hydrogen masses 1 gram. EDIT: corrected atomic mass of carbon. Not sure what I was thinking there ...
- kragen 16y agoAs it turns out, a mole of carbon doesn't mass exactly 12/16 of a mole of oxygen or 12× a mole of hydrogen. (Carbon's average atomic mass is 12, not 14.) So you'd have to pick an atom. At present, the definition runs the other direction: a dalton is defined as 1/(Avogadro's number) of a gram. But Avogadro's number is a little difficult to measure directly; what you end up doing is picking an element and measuring its atomic mass. They picked carbon. It seems to me that the definition you describe would indeed be a reasonable one, since Avogadro's number is known to seven significant figures at this point, which seems comparable to the mass stability of the international prototype kilogram.
- tassl 16y agoUnless they have changed the definition, back when I studied it the mole was defined as the number of particles found in 12 grams of C (C-12), 6.022*10^23. So the mole depended on the gram.
- michaelcampbell 16y agoInteresting article, but they kept trying to build a strawman about how Americans don't care about the metric weights since it doesn't affect their price of butter.