5 ms·
IMHO it is a little sad reflection of humanity that people enjoy destroying things purely for entertainment, as I'm sure most of their viewers aren't watching f
by userbinator 6y ago
IMHO it is a little sad reflection of humanity that people enjoy destroying things purely for entertainment, as I'm sure most of their viewers aren't watching for any scientific aspect. On the other hand, YouTube has plenty of content on creation and restoration; a lot of the latter which are unfortunately also fake.
- spaghettios 6y agoBest I’ve heard for the primate-cruelty phenomenon is “the brain seeks stimulation.” First-world countries are spoiled and don’t have to make do - easy to run over the latest iPhone with your car and get 1.3M clicks. I agree; it’s lazy. Not Russian, but as a Hacker News old timer: “old soviet tools restoration” [sic] by “Great idea” on YouTube is what you’re after. (Restoration of rusty old anvil.) It’s very hacker meta... building child tools to fix the parent tools is heartwarming, and at some level reminds me of many a build script.
- ars 6y ago> as I'm sure most of their viewers aren't watching for any scientific aspect Watching what happened when he compressed a book was very very scientific to me, I've wondered that for ages, and the answer was not what I expected at all. The scientific value you get depends entirely on the questions the viewer has. I'm 100% certain that there's at least one object that any particular viewer is curious "what would happen", as opposed to just "see it break".
- ObsoleteNerd 6y agoThe sheer depth/breadth of Youtube's maker scene is awe inspiring. There's orders of magnitude more people creating/restoring stuff on Youtube than there are people destroying stuff. The number of channels dedicated to restoring cars, building dioramas, making knives/tools, restoring old electronics, inventing new electronics, cooking, painting, etc etc... it's truly awesome (in both meanings of the word) and I personally love that Youtube has brought all this to the world. I don't even watch TV/movies anymore, I just have 200+ subscriptions to talented makers of all varieties, even stuff I personally have no intention of ever trying, just because it's so great to watch. After all that, I don't really fault people enjoying some things being crushed, same reason lots of people like seeing big crashes in motorsports or big explosions. It's a part of human nature.
- friendlybus 6y agoWhats your top reccomendations for channels we might not know? I like Rose Anvil for boot deconstruction and learning how good boots are made.
- bigbubba 6y agoThey have quite a few videos where they make things. Their videos get recommended to me alongside videos from machinists and fabricators.
- aaron695 6y agoWhat the difference between destroying a toy helicopter for millions of viewers and eating a large steak at a restaurant and shitting it out? The helicopter is far less destructive and people get to moral grandstand? It's highly efficient.
- weikju 6y agoEating the steak will at least provide sustenance to my body. Perhaps need to find a different comparison..
- tomcam 6y ago> I'm sure most of their viewers aren't watching for any scientific aspect. How do you measure what's on other peoples' minds?
- viraptor 6y agoLet's be honest - the viewers of the creation / restoration videos do it primarily for fun too. The common creator / community / lurkers ratio split applies to those videos as well. Who's to say that watching creation of something simple is better than watching a hydraulic press ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- dkdk8283 6y agoThis is absurd. Crushing stuff is entertaining, and the hydraulic press channel does a great job. Building stuff is fun, and so is destroying it. I would love to crush my phone or laptop sometimes. I also really enjoy the 11foot8 channel. Pity they raised the height of the bridge.
- Smithalicious 6y agoSadly there exists things I don't like. On the other hand, there are plenty of things I do like, but those are also unsatisfactory for vague ill-defined reasons. A sad reflection of humanity.
- majewsky 6y agoIt's always better to have a million people watch a video of one book being destroyed by a hydraulic press than to have a million people destroy one book each with a hydraulic press.