4 ms·
> If you say to me that the ideal solution is to simply have a more educated populace, I wouldn't disagree. However, that doesn't solve things now. Even in the
by AnimalMuppet 6y ago
> If you say to me that the ideal solution is to simply have a more educated populace, I wouldn't disagree. However, that doesn't solve things now.
Even in the long term, how are you going to produce this more educated populace? Or rather, who are you going to entrust with the task? The same educational establishment that produced the current populace?
But even if you can produce your more educated populace, you still have the problem that the Russian trolls aren't going to stand still. They're going to be better, too, by then.
- Trombone12 6y agoWhat is the end goal of this argument? That everything is great now?
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoHardly. Things are a mess. But if your solution involves having (or making) "better people", your solution likely won't work in the real world.
- airtonix 6y agoHow do you imagine such an educated population occurs when you conflat Freedom of Thought with Freedom of Speech? If you don't like certain ideas being distributed then who made you the boss of ideas? Without a free exchange of ideas, you can not have a educated population, you only get programmed automotons.
- JohnBooty 6y agoOr rather, who are you going to entrust with the task? The same educational establishment that produced the current populace?T Ideally, education teaches critical thinking, not a specific indoctrination. Education, obviously, often falls short of this ideal and you don't necessarily need formal education to be a critical thinker. I do think that's pretty achievable. When I went through school in the 80s and 90s we weren't exactly devoid of this sort of thing. Absurd ideas like chemtrails and flat-eartherism don't last very long in the face of the slightest hint of critical thinking. But even if you can produce your more educated populace, you still have the problem that the Russian trolls aren't going to stand still. They're going to be better, too, by then. I certainly don't disagree, but doing a better job of critical thinking certainly seems like a reasonable first step no matter what else we do.
- klyrs 6y ago> The same educational establishment that produced the current populace? Yes, them, but with adequate funding and a return of Civics and Home Ec required for all students.
- dahfizz 6y agoHow much funding is adequate? I'm so sick of hearing that throwing more money at X is our only solution. Per capita education spending has gone up significantly in the past 30 years.
- klyrs 6y agoEnough to pay teachers an enviable wage, so that the job is desirable and competitive, even in poor neighborhoods (not just the schools with good test scores). Funding education reduces crime, homelessness, poverty... it's not a magic bullet and you don't just get there by throwing money at the problem, but with good policy and adequate funding, education is just about the biggest payoff investments that we can make as a society.
- hackerfromthefu 6y agoFirst fix the leaking bucket .. remove the incentives for stupidity and uselessness and timewasting distractions that are rampant in western society. Then, money you spend on education will get a ROI instead of being skimmed off the top.
- klyrs 6y ago> remove the incentives for stupidity and uselessness and timewasting distractions that are rampant in western society. Kind of an awkward take... this conversation is literally taking place on social media. Do you have a concrete proposal for how to accomplish that goal?
- hackerfromthefu 6y ago