3 ms·
PINs seem like the wrong focus? The first thing to know is that payment cards have two almost unrelated systems, named Authorization and Settlement. Authorizat
by tialaramex 6y ago
PINs seem like the wrong focus?
The first thing to know is that payment cards have two almost unrelated systems, named Authorization and Settlement. Authorization is about protecting the card company from crooked card holders by validating that the card holder authorized this transaction. It's optional, and it has some modern technologies like EMV (Europay/Mastercard/Visa the joint system known for the presence of a chip on your card) which could enable PIN verification if you wanted.
Settlement is the part that moves money from your account to a merchant's account, it's childishly simple and it is run almost entirely on the honour system like it was when it was invented last century. A merchant says card 1234 5678 9012 3456 was used to pay them $280, the card company either accepts that and moves $280 from the account associated with that card to the account for the merchant, or they refuse. The merchant can provide more information, but they don't have to and will usually get paid regardless.
The fancy modern technology for Authorization makes no difference to Settlement. If the bank receives a Settlement for a transaction supposedly made with a card you actually tossed into the mouth of an active volcano a month earlier, the only thing likely to stop that getting paid is if you call the bank and insist you made no such transaction, confident that the merchant doesn't have evidence to the contrary because duh, that card was destroyed a month ago.
Check your statements. Read every line item, dispute anything you don't recognise. Even if you use (for example) Apple Pay every single time, your bank is under no obligation to treat a $150 payment for scratch offs supposedly made with a mag stripe card on the far side of the country as suspicious and block it. They might, but they might not, that's on you.
The volume of fraud is driven by easy ways to steal a shared "secret" that should never have existed (a card number, the only thing truly needed for Settlement) and then use that to fraudulently obtain things of value. PINs don't really impact that, they're a defence against a much rarer crime - theft of the card. A pickpocket or burglar doesn't know your PIN. But pickpockets do not steal millions of cards at a time.
If you have a card, with a PIN, and you used that card, with a PIN, at Dickey's, there is every chance you're vulnerable as a result of this anyway. Do the crooks get your PIN? Nope. But chances are your priority wasn't keeping a four digit number secret but not losing your money.
- zxcvbn4038 6y agoLast time I looked at card processor you had to echo back the approval numbers with the other information when you did your batch close transaction, so the card processor should be able to reconcile the batch record with the original approval record and stop arbitrary new data being introduced. Plus not every card processor I looked at used batches. At one point the card processors had a very nice crypto protocol called SET that kept the card numbers out of everyone’s hands. At the time the crypto was really overwhelming and it would take like twenty seconds to do all the math on a high end (for the time) processor. The other problem was that the reference implementation was done by an absolute c++ zealot who was furious he had to write the code in C so tens of thousands of lines of code was dedicated to implementing all the c++ features in C which pretty much made the reference useless except for interoperability testing. Unfortunately the standard never took off and you can’t find it anymore.
- rowls66 6y agoThe card processors have a new standard. Its called Secure Remote Commerce (SRC). Its the same ideas as SET. The card networks hold the card details securely, and issue crypto graphically signed digital tokens. We will see if it works out any better than SET.
- Spooky23 6y agoI had an issue that sounds like that settlement issue with a card where it would be used at a 7/11 in LA for like $11-15 every week for a few months. (Never been to LA in my life) The weird thing was that I’d get hit with an anti fraud decline getting gas in NY or Mass 50 miles from home, and it kept happening even after card replacement.