4 ms·
Um, WebKit? Granted they forked and renamed KHTML, and take maybe a little too much credit because of it, but they really propelled KHTML/WebKit to the top in
by tlrobinson 18y ago
Um, WebKit?
Granted they forked and renamed KHTML, and take maybe a little too much credit because of it, but they really propelled KHTML/WebKit to the top in the last couple of years. IMHO, WebKit is the premiere browser engine at this point, and I doubt it would be without Apple's involvement.
- crescendo 18y agoThe WebKit team is fantastic. Their code is clean, well-organized, fast, and their output prolific—every morning when I do update, there are at least 50 individual commits. They also beat all of the big-name players to Acid 3 compliance.
- ken 18y agoAlso: CUPS, Darwin, launchd, Bonjour, BLAST, Headerdoc, ... Also they call it "open source", and say they love it. You can go to an "Open Source" webpage at apple.com and see how to download source from CVS, and how to install and run other open-source programs (like PostgreSQL and MySQL) on Mac OS X. It's hard to imagine how a company selling proprietary software could be any more open-source friendly.
- wheels 18y agoI know it appears this way, but Apple really is a huge pain in the ass here. For a long time you couldn't download tar files of those things on their Open Source site -- you could only browse file-by-file through the web interface. This excepted the things that they were trying to push as standards. Most of the stuff you still can't get from CVS. It took forever when I was trying to track down the source for their libtool a couple years back; when I finally did I patched it to use half of the memory of their version (at the time it was using 1.5 GB just to link some stuff where I worked) and sent the patches in to mailing lists and filed them in a bug report. Never heard anything from Apple on either. The biggest case where that's not true -- where Apple has been pretty integrated into the community development processes from the beginning isn't any of the projects you mention -- it's GCC. Usually they just do what they need to to meet the license requirements.
- SwellJoe 18y agoUm, iPhone? By most measures, it's the least open smart phone platform.
- tlrobinson 18y agoTotally irrelevant. The article is about whether Apple contributes back to the open source community, not whether or not their platform is "open". But since you brought it up, Apple has contributed to several open source projects as a direct result of the iPhone projects. WebKit, for one. LLVM is another: "continued development and support of LLVM is funded by Apple Inc., ..."
- s3graham 18y agoYup, LLVM is awesome, and a quite R&D heavy project that doesn't directly really translate into a user product.
- SwellJoe 18y agoTotally irrelevant. The article is about whether Apple contributes back to the open source community, not whether or not their platform is "open". If you believe the two are unrelated, then we have widely differing beliefs about why Open Source is important. Open Source and Free Software is about freedom to do what you want with the software you use...Apple is not fond of that idea, and never has been. Sending money, and/or some snippets of code, to Open Source developers is wonderful...but it doesn't make a company a friend to Open Source or a friend to freedom. Apple is not an Open Source friendly company. They're not even an open standards friendly company, except where it suits them. And, I guess I need to point out that WebKit is not some generous gift to the world. Apple was required, by law, to release the source they produced. That they did so is not something to be praised. It's just doing business legally. So, sure, Apple contributes to some Open Source projects...and that's a good thing. But Apple is hostile to openness on many fronts, and that is a bad thing.
- tlrobinson 18y agoSo is Apple required by law to maintain webkit.org with extensive documentation, a frequently updated blog, nightly builds, an active IRC channel with hundreds of users, a public bug tracker, etc? Are they required by law to fund LLVM development? My point is that Apple does much more than contribute "snippets of code". Perhaps not every aspect of their business lives up to your ideal, but I think most of their involvement in open source projects does.
- wheels 18y agoThey did that kicking and screaming after many, many promises of finally opening up and never doing it, huge undocumented code drops, massive style inconsistencies and so on. It took years for Webkit to get around to the level of openness that it's at today, and being cynical, that wasn't because Apple wanted to give back to the OSS community; it was because they wanted Nokia on board. I contributed some very minor portions back in the KHTML days, and am friends with all of the original KHTML developers, so I watched this unfold. To be fair, this wasn't the fault of the Webkit developers, but as mentioned in the article, Apple's ultra-secretiveness and development timelines.