5 ms·
You’re mischaracterizing how free speech was viewed in the recent past. “Free speech” (as a cultural value, I’m not talking about the first amendment) was about
by rayiner 6y ago
You’re mischaracterizing how free speech was viewed in the recent past. “Free speech” (as a cultural value, I’m not talking about the first amendment) was about the marketplace of ideas: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marketplace_of_ideas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marketplace_of_ideas. It meant a free market in ideas, where the dominant ideas arise from competition. What you call “amplification” is just something that makes the marketplace more efficient—it allows ideas to disseminate faster so people can decide which are the good ones and the bad ones. The curation you mention is the antithesis of a free market of ideas.
- canjobear 6y agoI understand the theoretical argument, but empirically do you think the quality of ideas that people believe has increased from (say) 2000 to 2020? It seems like there's a lot more going on than just faster dissemination, and the way information travels these days might have introduced new asymmetries and inefficiencies.
- rayiner 6y agoI think the quality of ideas has improved. We focus on disinformation, but social media gets used for a lot of other things. Reading a dry article on police brutality (which let’s face it, people just skipped over in the past) is a lot less impactful than seeing something shared by a friend. I think we’re overestimating the effect of social media. A certain group of highly educated urban liberals is shocked by Trump. (And I don’t say this pejoratively. My college educated friends were literally despondent after he was elected.) And they’re looking for an explanation. And it so happened that social media became a major force around the same time. But I think that’s mostly, though not completely, a coincidence. Social media didn’t create Trump. Right wing populism is happening all over the world, in Europe, India, etc. Its a reaction to liberalism and globalism that’s been brewing for decades. And social media didn’t create Trump’s audience. My mom, a 70-year old Bangladeshi woman who has voted straight ticket Democrat since she was naturalized, thinks Trump is too unpolished, but loves his “energy” and “vigor.” She thinks he would be a “great President” if he could “implement his ideas.” My mom doesn’t have a Twitter account. (I think she’d love Boris Johnson, i.e. Trump with a bit more polish and competent.) She didn’t get this from Breitbart. She watches CNN in a loop all day. Social media isn’t not a factor, but I think folks overestimate how much of a factor.
- saluk 6y agoI'm not surprised at how your mom reacts to Trump. I'm surprised so many young people believe that covid is no big deal. I agree with you that the quality of our ideas has improved, but I also disagree in that the spread of our bad ideas has also improved. Concepts that were held by a fringe of society in the past, like the idea that the Earth is flat have grown their own communities who have interests in keeping those ideas alive. Ideas, bad and good, have gotten a lot stickier. With stickier ideas, the marketplace becomes worse, because nothing ever gets pruned out of it. Too much energy is spent on limiting the growth of bad ideas than can be spent on refining the better ideas.
- tux1968 6y ago> I'm surprised so many young people believe that covid is no big deal. Have you ever entertained the idea that perhaps you're wrong and they're right? I mean it's at least possible that you've been lead to the wrong conclusion by systemic errors that have yet to be identified, and perhaps wont be for many years into the future.
- bosswipe 6y ago> Right wing populism is happening all over the world, in Europe, India, etc. Social media is happening all over the world. > A certain group of highly educated urban liberals is shocked by Trump. 3 million more people voted for Hillary than Trump. Biden is polling 10 points ahead of Trump.
- TedDoesntTalk 6y agoIf you are in favor of the popular vote movement, how do you reconcile that for residents of sparsely populated states like Wyoming? Why would such residents bother to vote at all under the popular vote? (I would not)
- heurist 6y agoParties would realign to more evenly split the electorate. Wyoming would still count.
- koolba 6y agoAmerica is all about quantity. And the quantity of ideas has exploded in the 21st century. We’re still figuring out how to find the pearls but giving carte blanche to a handful of tech monopolies is definitely not going to work.
- leptons 6y ago>America is all about quantity. America used to be about quality. Sure, quantity was still a thing but the "shining city on the hill" image of America was about quality. We've lost our way.
- abduhl 6y ago"Keep, ancient lands, your storied pomp!" cries she with silent lips. "Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, the wretched refuse of your teeming shore. Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me, I lift my lamp beside the golden door!" America has never been about quality. Quality is a result of vigorous and excessive competition.
- bontaq 6y agoIt is sort of funny to say, "America has never been about quality," while referencing a poem about immigrants who moved here for a better quality of life. I think you've missed something rather obvious.
- syshum 6y agoI do, but I also do not use or consume content from Either Facebook or Twitter so....
- rhino369 6y agoSame as it always was. My Trump supporting uncle on facebook was just a Pat Buchnnan supporting uncle at a bar.
- mattigames 6y agoThat's not how it works in reality, in reality a lot of gullible people who before internet would have spend their whole lives without hearing the "flat earth theory" now have access to internet and are quickly influenced by a lot of stupid theories because they are pretty bad at distinguishing bad ones from good ones; although just to be clear that is more a failure of the education system than anything else (e.g Japan has near 0 flat-earthers unlike America)
- nunja 6y agoExactly. People seems to forget that the social landscape of people using Internet in 90/2000s was totally different. As far as I remember, internet was then populated by idealist early adopters, gamers / tech savvy hobbyists. Part of this pool translated to conservative boomers and now Internet is considered as a serious thing.
- RonanTheGrey 6y ago> are quickly influenced by a lot of stupid theories because they are pretty bad at distinguishing bad ones from good ones; Actually this is an interesting problem to think about; what, then, did these people believe before they could get access to crazier ideas? I think you'll find the answer was still, "what they were told to believe". The answer hasn't changed from then to now, we're simply far more aware of being upset at the answer. In a way the problem that was always there has been revealed and some people don't like the loss of control over these people's opinions. Me personally I'm an advocate of "let go, stop controlling, see how things turn out" and then fix the real problems that appear, rather than creating worse problems by squeezing the play doh too tightly. It has the upside of being morally defensible rather than having the air of "I destroyed your life for your own good."
- tunesmith 6y agoYou're defining "dominant ideas" as the ones that make people the angriest and get the most clicks! That's not the same as quality. That's entirely how those amplification algorithms exist!
- mmmeff 6y agoWe need to invest in education to vaccinate the population against deception via clickbait.
- mattigames 6y agoYep, countries with a greater average IQ have much less people believing dumb theories (e.g about bill gates and covid-19), countries like Japan and South Korea. All countries that reduced funds for public education years ago in a short-sighted attempt to save money are seeing it's dire consequences, and now amplified thanks to the internet.
- rayiner 6y agoEveryone who could vote in 2016 grew up in an age of ever increasing educational funding: https://images.app.goo.gl/ovrFXSUJaJ8tHBTBA https://images.app.goo.gl/ovrFXSUJaJ8tHBTBA
- mattigames 6y agoTeachers still complain they have to pay for school supplies from their pockets [0] [1], and if the money is not going to them I wouldn't really call it educational funding [0] https://amp.reddit.com/r/teaching/comments/528u9w/teachers_of_reddit_can_you_support_yourself/ https://amp.reddit.com/r/teaching/comments/528u9w/teachers_o... [1] https://www.google.com/amp/s/time.com/longform/teaching-in-america/%3famp=true https://www.google.com/amp/s/time.com/longform/teaching-in-a...
- rayiner 6y agoIf you mean “school fiscal responsibility” and not “educational funding” then say that. They are two different things with different solutions.
- glenstein 6y agoI don't think I agree that they are mischaracterizing how free speech understood, and I don't think that distinction you are drawing identifies a new idea incompatible with what they are saying. Free speech encompasses a lot of things depending on what you want to emphasize, including a notion in a healthy democracy the best ideas survive critical scrutiny. As other have mentioned, I think however plausible that conception of speech was then, it's utterly ignorant of the problems we're facing today, where ideas spread for reasons that have nothing to do with merit. If anything, I would think you would want to agree with the person you are replying to that the spread of ideas is not due to good ones rising to the top in a marketplace that is selecting for quality.
- throwaway2048 6y agoTwo keys to an actual functional market place, as you allude to, involves both good faith engagement (you aren't going to convince somebody deliberately out to cause harm to stop with a well reasoned argument) and critical evaluation (something that is practically non existent on most of the internet)
- legolas2412 6y ago> As other have mentioned, I think however plausible that conception of speech was then, it's utterly ignorant of the problems we're facing today I think it is the exact opposite. Maybe I have read too many dystopian novels like fahrenheit 451, or 1984, or read too much about Chinese govt's control of its population, but I feel that modern technology has allowed too much censorship power in hands of not just the govt, but a few corporations. And it is extremely important that we do not compromise on free speech now.
- glenstein 6y agoWe're dealing with the net result of a few different forces. Social media has enabled a massive avalanche of misinformation, and of this massive avalanche of misinformation, some subset of that new avalanche gets removed. The net effect is that there much more misinformation than there has ever been before. Despite the best efforts of twitter, facebook & youtube they appear to have been virtually powerless to halt the spread. The problem of social media CEOs having too much power is real, and has wrought real damage: Zuckerberg's naive ideas on speech have lead to far too much harm, and now that he's recovering from his free speech trutherism and implementing reforms it's too little, too late. Lastly I would say that if you are looking at this state of affairs and seeing 1984 or fahrenheit 451, you're seeing things wrong. There are fair examples of that, e.g. Hong Kong, mainland China. But the western internet doesn't fit that at all.
- rbanffy 6y ago> What you call “amplification” is just something that makes the marketplace more efficient Most efficient in generating engagement for selling banners, not in lifting up the most correct or useful ideas. Was it is, it's pure marketplace manipulation.
- enraged_camel 6y agoYeah but the issue isn't good ideas and bad ideas and a marketplace where they can be disseminated. We're talking about facts and truth vs. misinformation and actual lies. And in that context, Mark Twain's saying comes to mind: a lie can travel halfway around the world before truth can finish putting on its shoes. This is infinitely more true today since the lies in question are manufactured to be as inflammatory and scandalous as possible, so as to keep their consumers engaged, and they can be spread to entire audiences with the click of a button.
- wslack 6y agoI don't think moving viral misinformation from chain e-mail to hyper-spread tweets via algorithm has improved the marketplace of ideas.
- SquishyPanda23 6y ago> What you call “amplification” is just something that makes the marketplace more efficient—it allows ideas to disseminate faster so people can decide which are the good ones and the bad ones. Can you cite empirical research showing that the process works the way you believe it does?
- btbuildem 6y agoThat's lofty and all, but all we got in the end was Boaty Mc Boatface. Turns out the most popular things will be the most inane -- by definition, because they appeal to most people. And so we amplify beige slurry.