3 ms·
I’m sorry but this just fetishizes environmental disaster. Some reporter is surprised that mining produces waste and writes about it like one small lake is poi
by colechristensen 6y ago
I’m sorry but this just fetishizes environmental disaster. Some reporter is surprised that mining produces waste and writes about it like one small lake is poisoning the planet. Yes it could probably be done better with better environmental standards but waste is waste and setting aside small areas of the planet for it isn’t equivalent to some global catastrophe.
So many people seem to be living in this bubble where the only thing they experience is the clean interfaces to civilization and then they talk about the messy bits like the slightest blemish is doom.
A dispassionate analysis of the site might have painted a more convincing argument for something being wrong, but as it is, it reads like a melodramatic fainting after seeing some trash.
There are plenty of very real environmental issues, but if you sensationalize everything that isn’t pristine natural beauty, it doesn’t matter because your motivations have moved from reason to superstition.
- hinkley 6y agoWhen water was a source of power and transport, we made a habit of building industry right on bodies of water. When we switched to other ways to transport goods and power, we never stopped that tradition and I wonder how harshly future generations are going to judge us for doing so. We aren't using the river, but the river is still the same form of transportation it ever was. We don't barge away the goods, but the river will still happily carry any toxic materials that leave the factory by malice, incompetence, human error, or a series of unfortunate events (Fukushima). I mean at this point, building a factory where you swear not to pollute next to a geographical feature that makes it easy to pollute without getting caught or where any honest mistake is magnified... it feels like a teenager hovering by the display of expensive stuff and saying they are just looking, or playing catch in the living room. You won't be the least surprised when you find out there is something missing/broken. The solution isn't more yelling, it's taking away the temptation to misbehave, and/or reducing the consequences of doing so. We need public policy to build a proverbial glass cabinet around our core watersheds. Build highways, train and powerlines and zone for factories at a slight separation, along on the route between Here and There, where nothing we care about is directly downwind or downhill. Tennessee Valley Authority lost a dam and dumped years of fly ash into a tributary of the Mississippi. It's just a matter of time until deferred maintenance takes out this dam, and the lake remembers it was a river once.
- deepnotderp 6y agoWe most definitely still use cargo ships for freight transport.
- hinkley 6y agoWe definitely do, especially along the coasts, up the Missisippi, and along the Great Lakes, but we don't use them exclusively, and a lot of factories don't appear to use them at all. So in those cases, we get all the downsides and none of the advantages. Stated as a question: how often do brand new factories (or new enterprises in existing factories) use water for transport?
- colechristensen 6y agoAbout 5% of domestic and 60% of international freight for the US is by water by weight. It is not an easy comparison to do because the last mile distribution kind of freight gets mixed in with the raw materials kind of freight. Canada and Mexico aside, you can’t really do international trade without ships, in 2019 international trade volume was 10% of our GDP.
- wahern 6y ago> [T]hese waterways annually moves over 500 million tons of commodities, including petroleum products, farm inputs (e.g., fertilizer), coal, and grains--accounting for 4% to 5% of total commercial tonnage shipped in the United States. High-value cargo in containers rarely moves on the inland or intracoastal waterways. https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF11593 https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF11593 So it seems you're correct--factories don't ship via inland and intracoastal waterways. But they appear to be extremely important for low-value commodities, such a grains: > America's farmers depend on the inland waterways for more than 60 percent of our farm exports. https://www.mvp.usace.army.mil/Portals/57/docs/Navigation/InlandWaterways-Value.pdf https://www.mvp.usace.army.mil/Portals/57/docs/Navigation/In...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- corty 6y agoEspecially since the article contains lots of cluelessnes about the meaning of their reported facts: Clay that is radioactive at three times the normal background is called: normal clay. Your living room might be three times above background because of Potassium-40 in the wall bricks. Totally normal and harmless, except if you want to stir a panic among the clueless.