3 ms·
There's a ratio of "how much energy can be stored by a device" vs "how much energy did it take to create" graph halfway down this page: https://www.lowtechmaga
by zdw 6y ago
There's a ratio of "how much energy can be stored by a device" vs "how much energy did it take to create" graph halfway down this page:
https://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2018/05/ditch-the-batteries-off-the-grid-compressed-air-energy-storage.html https://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2018/05/ditch-the-batteries-...
TL;DR: Lithium ion batteries have a ratio of around 10:1, whereas compressed air or pumped water are 200:1 or better.
This is just storage - I'd be interested in the ratio on solar photovoltaic, wind, or similar power generation tech.
- StillBored 6y agoBTW: Surely for compressed air systems that are pumping into a high pressure container it would be possible to use a vacuum bottle design and solve the heat loss+add problem.
- jbay808 6y agoAlong these lines, MIT Prof. Alex Slocum's proposal was to build concrete domes underwater, and evacuate them to store energy / re-fill them to release energy. The pressure difference is the difference between vacuum and hundreds of atmospheres, and there are no compressible working fluids to cause adiabatic heating losses. https://newatlas.com/mit-offshore-wind-concrete-sphere-energy-storage/27357/ https://newatlas.com/mit-offshore-wind-concrete-sphere-energ... (Edit: better link)
- leafmeal 6y agoI was sceptical of this at first. I suspected that the "how much energy can be stored" was only in regards to a single use, but I checked out the source, and this is over the lifetime of the storage medium. It blows my mind that it takes 1/10 of the energy it will ever store to manufacture a lithium ion battery.
- Retric 6y agoConstruction energy is less than half the story here. The inefficiency of energy storage and retrieval dominates the energy costs of using a battery. You lose 10:1 on construction, and at least another 10:1 on electric-to-electric efficiency for a net of 5:1. However, with an electric-to-electric efficiency of only 40-52% compressed air has a net efficiency of ~ 0.5:1 even if construction costs suggest 200:1 that just means it stays 0.5:1.
- sk5t 6y agoIs it more or less mind-blowing to look around and note that virtually everything in our houses and offices--electronics, pots and pans, tables and chairs, autos, etc.--came out of the ground? Think about all the ore-bearing rock and soil that had to be mined, sifted, transported, refined, formed, milled, transported again, and so on, just to produce the machine that puts a label on a box. Even putting truly complex tech aside, the amount of resources we collectively tear through, day after day, to get to this (not particularly admirable) place is staggering.
- jonas21 6y agoI don't know if that's the right metric to look at. There's not a huge difference in going from 91% efficiency (10:1) to 99.5% efficiency (200:1). What's more concerning are the other negative externalities -- pollution, ecosystem destruction, etc, as described in the original article. This won't be captured by looking at energy stored vs. energy used in production.
- jayd16 6y agoDoes the math work out? If you have a phone battery for only a year, that's 365 charge cycles of a 3000mAh battery. At $0.20 a kWh you end up with less than a dollar for a year's worth of power. 3000mAh*3.8v /1000 = 13.3Wh in a phone battery. 13.3Wh * $0.20/kWh * 365 ~= $0.95 a year Even at 10 years of life, it takes a dollar of energy to make a battery at a 10:1 cost? Seems like a fine trade.
- layoric 6y agoFor power generation, the stat commonly used is “EROI” or “EROEI” Eg energy returned on energy invested. This is sometimes expressed in time range (which depends on average generation rate based on where it is installed etc) or just energy vs energy ratio (Eg kWh to produce vs lifetime kWh generated) As others have said this statistic is not the whole picture, type of pollution generated due to the construction of the solar panel, wind turbine etc should vs other technology should also be take into account so this gets pretty complex pretty quickly. Some recent studies [0] show a break down of input/output for solar with Switzerland of 9-10:1, this is likely higher if panel was installed in Australia for example and goes into some detail showing a fairly minimal amount of storage in an electricity grid (8%) increases the amount of usable generation for wind and solar which improves that ratio. Wind I believe has a better EROI but has a lot more complexity when it comes to installation, maintenance so how much this is taken into consideration and will likely vary for onshore vs offshore installations. Numbers I’ve read before were in the 16-20:1 range but can’t find any decent study sources at the moment. Hope that helps. [0] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0301421516307066 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S030142151...
- pas 6y agoThat tl;dr is interesting, but note that batteries are optimzed for a lot of things (eg. energy density for easy mobility, recharge rate, safety), while larger storage systems are a lot more optimized for efficiency.