4 ms·
Asking for government support is really an admission of failure. It is an admission that the open source concept cannot survive on it's own merit in the market
by jqpabc123 6y ago
Asking for government support is really an admission of failure.
It is an admission that the open source concept cannot survive on it's own merit in the marketplace.
It is asking government to pick winners and losers by way of funding, instead of the marketplace.
What could possibly go wrong? Everyone knows that government lives on the cutting edge of technology and will always respond instantly to the open source community --- rather than say corporate donors and lobbyists. They would never demand things be steered in their direction.
As they say, be careful what you wish for --- you just might get it.
- elicash 6y agoLots of things couldn't survive on their own, but aren't failures at all. For example, we're currently subsidizing multiple vaccines for COVID-19 because it's important that we collectively take on the risk that a single one might fail. Those billions in spending to pay for something that might be worth $0 is worth it because it's likely at least some of the vaccines will be safe and effective. Sometimes things start out as unprofitable and then only later, because of those dollars invested, become profitable. Space, for example. Government investments in solar power have also been super important. Or, more relevant to Hacker News, how about ARPANET being funded by the military, and then later that funding going to the National Science Foundation? Eventually, of course, it got privatized.
- jqpabc123 6y agoCOVID-19 is a national emergency, open source is not. Vaccines easily survive on their own merit in the marketplace. Government funding is being used to speed up the process and insure redundancy in case of failure. ARPANET is another questionable comparison. A world wide, failure proof network had never been done at the time so the military subsidized the basic research and development. Once the basic R&D was done, the funding ended. I would be inclined to support new, innovative R&D but I am not willing to pay taxes simply to clone existing commercial software.
- elicash 6y agoI'm not saying you should, for example, support changing federal procurement regulations to favor open source software (though the author makes a strong point). Or that you should favor tax incentives for them. I was taking issue with your broader principle that "asking for government support is really an admission of failure." In fact, subsidies can be incredibly valuable for the societies that collectively pay for them. I think it's best to evaluate on a case-by-case basis. This author has done a ton of research and so I didn't like it being dismissed out-of-hand on principle. Here's the paper linked from the piece about procurement (need a free account to access): https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3355486 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3355486 Also, for the record, vaccines are highly subsidized, particularly for children. Those subsidies are one of the best things we've ever done as a nation.
- jedbrown 6y agoRequesting federal funding for interstate highways is really an admission of failure. It is an admission that the transportation infrastructure concept cannot survive on its own merit in the marketplace.
- jqpabc123 6y agoYes, absolutely correct. If the marketplace controlled the interstate highway system, every on and off ramp would have a toll booth --- not to mention that the roadways would likely receive minimum upkeep. Some things are simply unworkable under the "free market" and transportation is one of these --- but software is not.
- jedbrown 6y agoClearly there are toll roads and many other forms of commercially viable "free market" transportation, so your argument is that some forms of transportation demand public funding. The same applies to software: like cheap and versatile transportation, libraries and infrastructure are force multipliers for commercially-viable and public-interest products. Despite such software being heavily used in industry, there's a lot that is funded from a combination of public sources (e.g., a side-effect of federally-funded basic research by groups with deeply-held open source convictions) and volunteer effort. This could be improved by direct public funding or by tax incentives for companies that contribute to independently-governed open source projects. Either way, it takes legislators recognizing that open source infrastructure has sufficient value to create policy that helps sustain it.