3 ms·
One of the problems is that most of what people call ‘bugs’ or relevant ‘information’ about Apple is actually false. It’s easy to see the scenario in which dev
by zepto 6y ago
One of the problems is that most of what people call ‘bugs’ or relevant ‘information’ about Apple is actually false.
It’s easy to see the scenario in which developers simply blame a large proportion of the bugs in their own apps on Apple.
But - I agree this is a serious problem. There does need to be a way for real platform bugs and other issues to be discussed in public.
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago> It’s easy to see the scenario in which developers simply blame a large proportion of the bugs in their own apps on Apple. In Mac apps that use Sparkle for updates (lots of them), developers can put whatever they want in changelogs. I've definitely seen entries that go something like "Did XYZ to work around a bug in macOS Kitty Cat." I can't say whether these changelogs were accurate, but they don't appear to have brought about armageddon.
- zepto 6y agoDevelopers who use sparkle are generally a lot more experienced than many people who put apps in the App Store. That is by design. The App Store lowers the bar to entry and enables people who otherwise wouldn’t publish software to do so.
- saagarjha 6y agoNope, mine was certainly a bug in Apple’s tooling (and perhaps a beta OS release, I think?) and this prevented me from running tests for some platforms. I actually wrote it all up here, if you’re interested: https://saagarjha.com/blog/2019/01/11/mocking-capabilities-in-the-ios-simulator/ https://saagarjha.com/blog/2019/01/11/mocking-capabilities-i...
- zepto 6y agoFor sure - I am not saying it was your fault, and the fact that it wasn’t makes it especially galling. What I’m saying is that Apple is contending with a lot of developers who are not as experienced or conscientious as you, and you are being impacted because their rules don’t distinguish this.
- dkonofalski 6y agoExactly. I can see a million scenarios where a developer blames Apple for a bug in their app and puts it in the notes and then it turns out not to be anything related to Apple. Apple isn't going to get into a catfight with every developer who thinks their issue comes from a bug whether it does or not.
- mswtk 6y ago> One of the problems is that most of what people call ‘bugs’ or relevant ‘information’ about Apple is actually false. Is that actually a problem? Many other platforms have no such restrictions, and you don't see developers blaming bugs on the OS en masse. It honestly just doesn't seem to matter at all. The only reason Apple seem to be doing it, is that they can, and simply aren't able to stop themselves from being excessively controlling.
- zepto 6y agoSure but for what it’s worth, Apple isn’t in the same position as other platforms in many ways, so we can’t always generalize. People don’t care about problems other platforms have the way there care about Apple, and the media gets to make money out of the slightest issue. This is a consequence of their market position. That said, I do agree with you to some degree. Control is definitely a tool they reach for by default, and they need to learn some new methods as we see the limits exposed by issues like this.
- julianmarq 6y ago> Sure but for what it’s worth, Apple isn’t in the same position as other platforms in many ways, so we can’t always generalize. How? I see absolutely no difference other than millions in publicity to create the illusion that their platform is somehow "better"... But none of Apple's platforms were created by aliens, they have the same error ratio as any other large platform. So what exactly are you basing this statement on?
- zepto 6y agoI’m not convinced that all platforms have the exact same error ratio - that would be interesting if supported by research. But that’s irrelevant. My statement isn’t a comment on Apple’s error ratio. It’s a statement about how people respond to what they see as the market leader. People care about problems with Apple in a way that they don’t with other players, because they are perceived as better. There is money to be made in trying to tear Apple down. That’s just part of the dynamics of the attention economy. Whether this is just a function of spending on marketing, seems highly unlikely. My understanding is that Google and the Android manufacturers as a whole far outspent Apple in the early years of the iPhone, and didn’t end up with the same perception. In any case, however it was achieved, we do agree that they are perceived differently to the other players, and this is what my comment is based on.