6 ms·
HP-28S Battery Compartment Door
- bayindirh 6y agoThis brings a whole new angle to HP calculators' motto: "By Engineers, for Engineers". I actually love this little projects which extend the life of useful tools for a very, very long time.
- criddell 6y agoI have this calculator and for me, the case cracked around the battery door. I haven't put batteries in it in a long time, but IIRC the springs are very powerful and that plastic case is very strained there. My calculator is 30 years old now and I'm guessing the plastic is less elastic now than it used to be...
- bayindirh 6y agoPlastics have an ingredient called plasticizers to add elasticity and reduce brittleness. This materials sometimes evaporates or degrades over time, hence plastics become so-called dry and become brittle. This is why things crack over time and become more brittle. Some modern formulas are much more stable and can protect their properties for a longer time. Of course, we see the effects of this resiliency as pollution nowadays. Looks like we made some wrong choices while selecting the items to make more resilient.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoMy old HP 55 calculator is still looking like new, after what, nearly 50 years? They must have changed the case plastic at some point, for calculators after that one.
- rob74 6y agoLooks like the unit used for this picture on Wikipedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HP-28_series#/media/File:HP_28.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HP-28_series#/media/File:HP_28... could use one of these too (I assume the battery compartment door is in the upper right corner, where you can see some duct tape)
- numpad0 6y agoHow about ordering to somewhere running HP MJF printers? The PA11/PA12 materials they use is much like ABS or PLA but has no visible layer lines.
- criddell 6y agoIsn't MJF essentially the same process as SLS that was used in this project?
- mdorazio 6y agoNo. Microjet printers use a binder (like a glue/epoxy) with powders (usually ceramic) and sometimes add colors as well to achieve the end product. SLS uses a laser to melt together (sinter) the powder (in this case nylon, but could also be metal). They are both powder-based, but the method of turning the powder into the end result is quite different.
- beervirus 6y agoNeeds some acetone vapor smoothing. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NiG1jDEG0kA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NiG1jDEG0kA
- PacketPaul 6y agoDoes not work with PLA, only ABS.
- beervirus 6y agoOops, you're right.
- alphabetter 6y agoI am intrigued by the support for the 28S these days. I still have my 28S (with working battery door) from when I was at University. But, while I was impressed by it's potential, I never loved it as a device to use and I've stuck with my older FX-7000G as the calculator on my desk. As explained here (edit - not my site, but I agree with the POV): http://www.ganjatron.net/retrocomputing/hp-28s/index.html http://www.ganjatron.net/retrocomputing/hp-28s/index.html "I must say I have mixed feelings about this calculator. All this sophistication comes at the expense of ease of use. I find the HP-28S aggravatingly clumsy to use, and it's not because of RPN. For starters, the clamshell design, while ideal protection, is awkward -- you'll find yourself constantly flipping back and forth because keys on both sides are frequently used in typical operation. Another major problem is that the HP-28 is, for the most part, not keystroke programmable; most commands are indirectly accessible through menus (over 20 of them)." Not having the ability to import from exteral storage (the IR link is out-only) is also a big minus.
- mturmon 6y agoThat’s a good review of the 28S. I had the same issues with mine, To the extent that I’m not sure where it is now! I later got a 32Sii which is simpler, more focused, and better as a desk calculator. I had a 41cv for many years and loved it even more.
- SomeHacker44 6y agoYou can get a modern HP-41 from Swissmicros which just launched its DM-41X. I just received mine and it is a very nice device.
- goatinaboat 6y agoI have one too, it’s superb. Love that a business exists that is doing this.
- monkpit 6y ago32sii gang represent
- gilrain 6y agoEvery time I see a 3D printing project like this, I experience a mix of disappointment and hope for further progress. If the finished result is going to look so rough and unfinished, it's just not for me yet. If, in order for it to look good, I need to carefully sand the result and account for that sanding in the initial design, I might as well take up woodworking. Sanding is laborious.
- criddell 6y agoThe PLA print isn't any good, but the SLS print looks great IMHO. I don't think they needed to do much sanding on it at all.
- fdsafaeds 6y agoYea screw scanding, but I tthink you've got to accept that this is always going to be prevalant purely down to how 3d printing works. Acetone vapor chambers are where it's at, closest you'll get to a injection moulded piece without doing the injection moulding.
- PacketPaul 6y agoAcetone will only work with ABS which has another set of issues. Reducing the layer height and a coat of paint will accomplish almost the same thing using PLA.
- PacketPaul 6y agoThis is a bad example. The layer heights are too high. Look at thingiverse.com for examples of what you can do with a 3D printer.
- russh 6y agoThat's is my take as well, the PLA print is of poor quality.
- Damogran6 6y agoThere are better and worse examples of FFF printing. The current heavyweight printers from Creality, while being some of the cheapest you can buy, have been dialed in to the point they can make amazing output. The problem here is that you're zooming in on a 1x2 CM part...It's like taking a 12 Mpixel photo, then looking at a 320x200 size part of it...it'll still look pixelated.
- PacketPaul 6y agoAn FDM printer can absolutely do the job. My kids are always breaking the battery covers, which I recreate via a FDM printer without issue. He needs to realign how the part is printed, the layer height, and possibly nozzle size. He can also anneal the parts for added strength.
- njovin 6y agoAgreed. I’ve printed dishwasher replacement parts using ABS that hold up perfectly in high temps soaking in water. PLA is also great for certain applications and can look and feel very nice when done right.
- mayoff 6y agoThe design itself could also probably be made more FDM-friendly.
- mdorazio 6y agoDisagree, and I used to run a company that did FDM printing. If you look at this design it's packed with tons of overhangs regardless of printing orientation, and a particularly nasty undercut ending in a sharp point (see right side view). This is actually a great example of where FDM is a bad solution and the part should be redesigned (ex. split it into multiple pieces or find a way to re-engineer it so it can be printed in some good orientation) or you should pick a different method. Yes, you could FDM print this, but the end quality would be garbage, the tolerances would be poor, and you'd end up with a lot of support material cleanup and probably failed/unacceptable prints.
- Doxin 6y agoIf you print this angled so the curved side is down and the two sides are at 45 degrees to horizontal, it should print more or less fine without any support whatsoever.
- stmw 6y agoThis is great work... not specifically for 28S, but exactly what 3D printing should enable, more reuse and repair of otherwise working systems.
- Volt 6y agoThis seems like the wrong part of the door to fix.