3 ms·
Note also that, pedantically speaking, “Florence First” (Prima Firenze) is much closer to "London First" or "Los Angeles First" than it is to Brexit or "America
by 082349872349872 6y ago
Note also that, pedantically speaking, “Florence First” (Prima Firenze) is much closer to "London First" or "Los Angeles First" than it is to Brexit or "America First", which themselves are closer to Deutschland Über Alles.
- afiori 6y agoDuring Machiavelli lifetime Florence was a nation by itself.
- 082349872349872 6y agoA city state. Nations weren't much of a thing before the eighteenth century. Conversely, city-states are (pace Monaco, Singapore, etc.) not much of a thing now. Within the existing nation of the US, potential city-states would be: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_metropolitan_area#Economy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_metropolitan_area#Eco... (USD 1,8T would put it between italy and canada) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greater_Los_Angeles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greater_Los_Angeles (USD 1,3T would put it between australia and spain) Looking at https://apps.bea.gov/iTable/drilldown.cfm?reqid=70&stepnum=40&Major_Area=7&State=7&Area=XX&TableId=501&Statistic=1&Year=2018&YearBegin=-1&Year_End=-1&Unit_Of_Measure=Levels&Rank=1&Drill=1&nRange=5 https://apps.bea.gov/iTable/drilldown.cfm?reqid=70&stepnum=4... next would be the SF bay area, with 1T putting it between indonesia and the netherlands... S'pore itself (0,4T) would be between Miami and Detroit.
- afiori 6y agoBut New York (city), Los Angeles, or London are nothing like states/nations at a political or social level. The difference between a Nation and a city state are size and centralization, and in the case at hand Florence as a city state was not too much smaller than its neighbours in Italy. In this context I don't really see a meaningful distinction between city state and nations.
- 082349872349872 6y agoThe difference I see between a city state and a nation is that in the former people belong to it by being part of the same strongly economically connected component[1], while in the latter people belong to it by being part of some granfalloon[2]. Some nations share an ethnicity, some a language, some a religion. As my country shares none of those, we've fallen back on shared historical myths and shared cultural traits, such as celebration of diversity ("il faut de tout pour faire un monde"). Consider cities in Alsace: they retained their economic identity despite intermittently swapping nations for the last couple of centuries. Returning to Machiavelli, Firenze has been under roman, Odoacer's, Ostrogothic, byzantine, lombard, carolingian, monarchic, feudal, local republican, local aristocratic, monarchic, french revolutionary, monarchic, Savoyard, and monarchic regimes before being incorporated into republican italy. I'm having trouble thinking of a nation which has stayed constant while having its cities change instead. If Detroit had an army[3] and in principle set its own foreign policy, it would be considered a country just like Singapore. Consider the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_of_Monaco https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_of_Monaco , all few hundred of them, or https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_relations_of_Monaco https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_relations_of_Monaco . [1] from TFA: "... he means loyalty to Florence. He was a civil servant, serving regardless of regime; the Medici were hardly worse than many others. ... What mattered were family, friends, particularly circles of friends, lovers, the polis." [2] consider before the nation was a thing, when larger-than-city political entities were simple: all the land that currently belonged to the same monarch. [3] I'm not very familiar with the Detroit CSA, but it seems that of the local militia, at least four army companies are based in Detroit proper, so just the city proper, without land units from its periphery or the air wing at Selfridge, could probably field a larger military than Monaco.
- afiori 6y agoThis is an interesting point of view, to me it seems that we are using significantly different approaches. If I understand what you mean I disagree with this application of granfalloon. In most modern nations the bond between the people is that of shared trust, there is nothing that links me to someone living in a far away part of my country except a shared implicit assumption that we are probably slightly more predisposed to care about our country than the average random human. A bunch of people loosely connected by this is in my opinion not a granfalloon, as mutual trust is the stuff economies are made of. In this concept then there would be a spectrum of shared trust and cities states are mostly on the "more" side and nations more on the "less" side. I don't have a good name for the country where peripheric cities have little to no connection to their king except sometime paying taxes. I can form arguments for both calling such a city a state and for not calling such a city a state.