4 ms·
TFA already says that large scale CAES is probably a dead end and that small scale CAES is where we might/should focus our attention.
by PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago
TFA already says that large scale CAES is probably a dead end and that small scale CAES is where we might/should focus our attention.
- notmadnomad 6y agoCAES also has awful energy density of ~100 kJ/m^3 or ~100 J/L. It's not worth it. Small CAES implies closer to people and more likely to experience heat and fires, more so than say 200 psi / 13 atm air compressors, and so inherently more dangerous than all existing residential and commercial products including water heaters with failed/blocked relief valves. Perhaps almost on-par with LPG tanks, which are not supposed to be stored inside building either but in a remote pit or shed. Large amounts of reactive lithium metal in NMC (0.90–2.43 MJ/L) "powerwall" reserve banks in or on a building also seems like a major fire risk. LiFePO4 (1.2 MJ/L) is safer due to much less lithium. By comparison with fuels: - Al thermite is ~18 MJ/L - Cu thermite is ~21 MJ/L - hydrogen is ~28 MJ/L @ 700 psi - gasoline is ~32 MJ/L - Jet A is ~35 MJ/L - diesel is ~36 MJ/L In the long-term, a reliable, reversible fuel cell combined with H2 tanks and H2 generation and distribution infrastructure seems like the best hybrid on- / off-grid way to go, at deployment cost though, but it could eliminate the increasingly-dangerous electrical grid and natural gas grid. Short-term, LiFePO4 looks better and better.