3 ms·
Personal opinion I think a lot of opportunities for innovation and growth in the desktop OS market have stagnated, as increasingly 90% of what people do is cont
by walrus01 6y ago
Personal opinion I think a lot of opportunities for innovation and growth in the desktop OS market have stagnated, as increasingly 90% of what people do is contained within a browser window and performed through some sort of network-dependent cloud service/saas/web app. Inside chrome, edge, firefox, safari, whatever.
For many non technical consumer users it no longer really matters whether they're running Windows 10, MacOS or something weird like a linux+xorg/KDE desktop environment.
- mikewarot 6y agoI think that one of the primary reasons things have stalled is the fear we all carry around because we don't have any decent operating systems. With MS-DOS you could copy the OS disk, write protect it... load up any random piece of shareware and just try it out. There was zero chance it would toast anything, and you might find a gem. We don't click on links that go to web sites we don't trust. We don't open email attachments, we're paranoid... because our operating systems weren't designed for the age of the internet.
- walrus01 6y agosome method to reliably run new stuff in a fully sandboxed environment (short of going through the time and effort to copy an entire disposable windows 10 home virtualbox machine), would definitely help with that problem. linux based ideas like qubes are are a step in that direction.
- OCASM 6y agoSandboxie is a good option. Development stopped but on the flipside it's fully free now.
- fuzzfactor 6y agoOnce your full C: volume is backed up to a WIM file it's not too bad even on bare metal. If you keep C: under about 20GB, the resulting WIM is about half that size and easy to deal with. To deploy using a 30GB partition it only takes about 5 minutes to write zeros to the 30GB, another 5 minutes to quickformat and deploy the WIM file to the fresh partition (in naturally well-defragmented condition), then a judicious BCDBOOT command to make it boot from your present BOOT or EFI folder.
- walrus01 6y agothat is a great deal slower than the time it takes me to duplicate a ready-to-go windows 10 home virtualbox VM, copying about 25GB of data SSD-to-same-SSD, and then run it.
- linguae 6y agoI agree. With the exception of the Linux desktop, desktop computing is controlled by two very large companies: Microsoft and Apple. Microsoft still makes plenty of money from Windows licenses, but its business model has become more reliant on its cloud offerings. 15 years ago Apple was virtually synonymous with the Mac, but today the iOS platform far outstrips the Mac in terms of revenue. Back when there was money to be made selling personal computers, we got innovation. But now that Apple is making tons of money from its iPhone/iPad ecosystem and Microsoft is increasingly becoming a cloud vendor, innovation on the desktop has stagnated, in my opinion. Moreover, the desktop is a very difficult market to enter. Writing a new desktop environment that is competitive with even Windows 7 and Mac OS X Snow Leopard is going to take a lot of work, even if they piggyback on existing operating systems such as Linux in order to avoid the full work of writing a new operating system. Moreover, where is there a viable business model for selling desktop operating systems? Be, Inc. tried with BeOS in the 1990s; the company had a hard time getting PC companies to agree to shipping their PCs with BeOS preinstalled due to agreements these companies had with Microsoft regarding preinstalling Windows. There's also the problem with software incompatibility, though, interestingly enough, this may be less of an issue today than it was in the 1990s due to the dominance of the Web and due to the "Electronization" of desktop applications. My opinion is such innovation on the desktop will come from a hobbyist open-source project or from a small business that is willing to cater to a niche of users who want compelling alternatives to Microsoft, Apple, and various Linux desktops.