2 ms·
Your anecdata doesn't refute the article, which uses data (such as the astonishingly high ADD diagnosis rate for boys). Asking for fixes to systemic issues (e.
by smt88 6y ago
Your anecdata doesn't refute the article, which uses data (such as the astonishingly high ADD diagnosis rate for boys).
Asking for fixes to systemic issues (e.g. pathologizing young children just because they can't sit still) doesn't negate girls' issues. We can work on both.
- im3w1l 6y agoDisclaimer: I have not gone to school in the US, so I'm not fully aware of the situation. I don't think it's an either or. Boys do need strict rules to some extent, and if there is a lack of them that can be a systemic issue too. But the rules need to take their nature into account, and give opportunities for physical exertion, with play and sports.
- hashmymustache 6y agoNot to mention boys have lower grade averages across the country and women make up almost 60% of college students. You don’t have to be a men’s activist to recognize that if those trends were reversed such a disparity would receive a lot of attention with social pressure to recalibrate the learning environment.
- uberman 6y agoYet somehow men make up the vast majority of senior positions in almost every field including college professors.
- smt88 6y agoAgain, I think you can separate these issues and care about both. Men dominating leadership positions is a problem. Men getting degrees at a much lower rate than women is also a problem. They have separate causes. It's not like every gendered trend is a tug-of-war with every other issue.
- uberman 6y agoThe article directly suggests altering teaching strategies to favor/accommodate boys that I believe will be at the expense of girls: * Lessons that are structured as competitive games. * Lessons requiring motor activity. * Lessons that require a combination of competition and teamwork. So, I guess I don't really see these as separate issues. I think it is also important to state that men don't just dominate leadership positions, we also typically dominate compensation as well and I'm not talking about equal pay in the context of women and men in different jobs. For example, men are the highest paid teachers and professors despite the reduced participation by men in higher ed. So my opinion remains that men do perfectly well with traditional instruction and we don't need to make adjustments to it to favor them, particularly not the types of adjustments that would disadvantage women.
- jfengel 6y agoUnfortunately, we need to fix both problems -- many boys don't do great with traditional instruction, and the problem of the many kinds of job and pay disparity. It's not really great to disadvantage them in school and then flip the disadvantage after graduation. I agree that it's worse to fix the one disadvantage without the other, which is tempting because it seems like the less-intractable one. Wage and job disparity is deeply ingrained; "women's work" has long been poorly compensated because women are seen as wanting to do that work. We lump a huge amount of effort under "homemaker" and don't pay for it at all. We then heap even more effort on women working outside the home, for which we don't even have a single name -- cleaning, note-taking, emotional labor, etc. -- unpaid and often marking one as less valuable. I don't have a good answer to this, and resist fixing the "easier" problem that puts girls at a disadvantage.
- LocalH 6y agoIt’s as if we made a mistake when we gave government control over education. It devolves into a lowest common denominator “one size fits all” approach that disadvantages heaps of people and prevents them from reaching their full potential
- uberman 6y agoThe article mentions ADHD once. It is clearly not the focus. But, yes over diagnosis of any form particularly when it leads to the unneeded medication of children is a huge problem. I think it is clear that I am not advocating dealing with boys by sedating them. I'm glad you raised this related issue though as I believe that many of the legions downvoting my opinion feel that somehow I am ok with that strategy. I feel that the systemic need to identify energetic and inattentive students and then solve those issues with medication is a travesty that rises directly as a result of increased classroom sizes resulting from school funding shortfalls. I'm not advocating that at all. What I am advocating is that teaching strategies in my opinion do not need to be altered to accommodate boys contrary to what I perceive the article to actually be about. Changes such as: * Lessons that are structured as competitive games. * Lessons requiring motor activity. * Lessons that require a combination of competition and teamwork. Boys (in general) are already proficient in learning though competition and movement, starkly opposed by middle school girls who (in general) are not, at least not when it comes to physical contests with boys. Boys just don't need lessons that reinforce competitive games and motor activity. If anyone would benefit, it would be girls but that would also likely require a single gender school system. Boys go on to dominate (almost) every profession so clearly altering middle school teaching strategies to favor and accommodate them at the expense of girls is both unneeded and would likely lead to larger systemic disadvantages to women.
- smt88 6y agoI understand your point, but I think you're combining a lot of different issues into a single argument. Yes, men dominate leadership of most fields. That's a widely known problem. The stats are glaring and blatant. It's difficult to fix, but we generally know some strategies that work. The challenge is building political will. This article is about a problem that is not widely known, which is obviously why she chose to write about it. Forgetting about whether elementary school performance results in leadership positions, first look at the effects of penalizing high-energy children (regardless of gender): - ADD over-diagnosis - poor grades due to teacher bias, which the article mentions (academic grades are artificially deflated based on unrelated behavioral issues) - school-to-prison pipeline (not mentioned in the article, but a huge problem for boys and not at a problem at all for girls) Maybe a solution would be to have gender-only schools, but that might cause other problems. It seems that most of the problems in education are a result of treating children as a homogeneous group instead of individuals, which is another thing this article points out. There may not be enough money to have individual lessons for children, but perhaps a more college-like system (where high-energy children can enroll in physical classes while low-energy children can choose to do something else) would work. For the record, I was extremely high-energy and not athletic at all. The solution for me was not to do competitive, physical classes. It was to do active classes that involved working (even if "working" was just filling out worksheets) instead of sitting still and listening to a lecture.