4 ms·
Keep in mind this entire article is based on players from the 1980s, before CTE was even named, let alone well-known. A think a big part of the ethical issue i
by bumby 6y ago
Keep in mind this entire article is based on players from the 1980s, before CTE was even named, let alone well-known.
A think a big part of the ethical issue is whether organizations like the NFL/NCAA 1) knowingly covered up information, shrouding the risk (presumably to protect their profit) and 2) whether they have a responsibility to the players whose health is sacrificed for those profits
* I realize both organizations are technically not-for-profit. IMO, it's a bit of an absurd classification and a big can-of-worms to open in the discussion
- lotsofpulp 6y agoI think a huge ethical issue is the continued existence of American football, especially for children, but also at colleges. Which means a huge cash cow for the NCAA disappearing.
- disown 6y ago> I think a huge ethical issue is the continued existence of American football I'm always curious why foreigners are so invested in anything american related, especially when they really don't even understand it. > especially for children Children really don't play football in a way that would cause these health issues. It's mostly two hand touch or flag. Even tackle football ( with or without equipment ) is mostly just grabbing and dragging down the qb, rb, wr, etc. > but also at colleges. College football ain't going anywhere. It's so entrenched in the culture. > Which means a huge cash cow for the NCAA disappearing. That has nothing to do with the "ethical issues" via health. It's another issue altogether and it affects NCAA basketball more than football.
- greedo 6y agoWhy are you assuming the poster is a foreigner? On a multinational message board like HN, I think referring to it as American Football is entirely appropriate. High school football is far more than just "dragging down" the opposition. There are tons of hits, big and small. For linemen, the smaller hits appear to be cumulative in damage, so the concern about concussions isn't the only major effect.
- disown 6y ago> Why are you assuming the poster is a foreigner? "american football". > On a multinational message board like HN, I think referring to it as American Football is entirely appropriate. HN is not a multinational forum. It's an american forum where anyone can participate. Also, the article is about USC linebackers. > High school football is far more than just "dragging down" the opposition. I don't really consider varsity/jv football players to be "children".
- anonAndOn 6y ago> Even tackle football ( with or without equipment ) is mostly just grabbing and dragging down the qb, rb, wr, etc You obviously have no idea what youth competitive football looks like these days. Check out Snoop Dogg's West Coast Steelers getting crushed by Fort Lauderdale's Hurricanes.[0]. BTW, these are elite level kids in middle school. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bPKmg3eGc3w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bPKmg3eGc3w
- Balgair 6y agoThat hit at 3:28 is very close to targeting. Not that an 8th grader should know to not do that. I mean, he's what, 13? But the refs and coaches aren't watching and guiding the kids well enough. That said, good on Snoop for sponsoring these activities.
- garmaine 6y agoThe organizations are not non-profits in the sense that any reasonable person ignorant of the particular tax laws would expect. The type of "non-profit" status the NFL has is as a pass-through organization. It takes money in, then redistributes it to its for-profit stakeholders, which then pay taxes. The "non-profit" status is merely to avoid double-taxation of the very much for-profit teams. They don't get any of the benefits you would expect of a real "non-profit", like tax-deductible charitable contributions.
- Igelau 6y ago> before CTE was even named, let alone well-known It wasn't named yet, and wasn't described using all the diagnostic tools we have at our disposal today, but it was very well-known. They were calling it "punch drunk". The phrase appears in the article. It's been widely known for a long time that repeated head traumas are really really bad for you and can come back to haunt you later in life. Just because they weren't calling it CTE doesn't absolve them of knowingly sending these kids into repeated harm.
- bumby 6y agoYou’re right and I should’ve been more specific. I don’t, however, think it was widely known outside the medical community. “Getting your bell rung” and wandering to the wrong huddle was something laughed about. I doubt people do that now because we’ve come to understand the deleterious effects. “Punch drunk” (and associated pugilistic dementia) was well known but I suspect most people did not think the long term effects extended beyond boxing (hence the names), where it’s literally one of the aims to cause head trauma (outside of Olympic point-style)
- monoideism 6y agoUniversities, even some individuals universities, have benefitted financially far, far more than the NCAA.
- klyrs 6y agoMany universities have separate athletics departments which are legally separate entities. The financial benefit goes to the department, not to the university.
- monoideism 6y agoA rose by any other name would smell as sweet.
- bumby 6y agoI agree, but I don’t think one point negates the other
- monoideism 6y agoOK, but it was an odd omission, if we're discussing organizations that financially benefitted from football.
- bumby 6y agoThe NFL is generally the main culprit when it comes to discussions about hiding evidence of the risk. I felt the NCAA was more analogous to the NFL
- monoideism 6y agoThat's a good point, and I see now where you were coming from, since you also didn't mention NFL teams. That said, from an ethical perspective, any lawsuits for CTE in football players should also include the universities would benefitted immensely from the program, particularly in the case of mega-programs like USC.