4 ms·
There is another aspect to this people might be missing: If every phone that is shipped must come with a charger, but half the chargers are never used, then th
by jiggawatts 6y ago
There is another aspect to this people might be missing:
If every phone that is shipped must come with a charger, but half the chargers are never used, then the marginal value gained by customers from the manufacturer improving that product is also halved.
So why bother making the charger good? Half the people won't use it! They'd have to pay for something that's not a direct benefit to the product they do want to buy: the phone.
This is one of the reasons the chargers that come with typical electronic devices are so bad. So very very bad.
They're big. They're odd shaped. They can't be plugged in side-by-side. They're heavy. The don't provide much power. They're inefficient. Etc... Some are downright dangerous.
It's a race to the bottom where noone wins.
Here's the thing: I like the "fancy" chargers Apple makes. They use very advanced technology such as gallium nitride circuitry to miniaturise their chargers. They're tiny, yet powerful! They don't get hot. They're light. They're safe.
But I only need one or two, but only when travelling. At home I need none because the IKEA power strips have USB charging ports built in!
I'd much rather concentrate my dollars into a couple of really good chargers instead of a bunch of mediocre chargers that's forced upon me on a one-to-one basis with the number of devices that I own.
Also: I haven't used a wired charger for my phone in about a year. Why include a wired charger if the customer has a choice of charging technologies? Should Apple include both a wireless and wired charger? Should they include a car-kit too?
No. This is the point of standards: it lets you mix and match components at will instead of getting a fixed combination.
- soperj 6y ago>This is the point of standards Except apple doesn't use standards. They use their own proprietary ports.
- mmm_grayons 6y agoIn fairness to Apple, they didn't just make other ports for the sake of it. When lightning mini was made, it was objectively better than mini-USB. When magsafe was made, it was objectively better than barrel plugs (and for charging, it's still better than USB-C.) Now that the standards are better, Apple is slowly transitioning to USB-C, which is a standard.
- samatman 6y agoIf by "slowly transitioning" you mean "massively and publicly driving adoption of USB-C", then yes, I agree. Apple has been pushing for the interoperable USB standard for as long as it has existed. The original iPhone was either the first phone to charge from USB, or at minimum the first successful mass-market phone to do so.
- sagarm 6y agoApple definitely did not lead on USB-C. Premium Android and Windows laptops standardized on USB-C long before.
- samatman 6y agoThe Apple MacBook was March of 2015. The Galaxy Note 5, released in August of 2015, used a MicroUSB port. I think we'd both agree that is a premium Android device, and clearly, "standardized on" USB-C did not happen "long before". In fact, Android only introduced support for USB-C in 6.0, officially released in October 2015: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USB-C#Software_support https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USB-C#Software_support So I'm quite sure your memory is faulty, on that one. Given that the specification for USB-C was only finalized in August of 2014, I'm confident your statement about Windows laptops is equally off base.
- kalleboo 6y agoHave windows laptops even standardized on USB-C now? I still see a lot of Windows laptops that come with barrel plug charging and all the legacy ports, and then have a sole USB-C port that you can also use for charging if you buy a separate charger
- firebird84 6y agoThe problem is if they have the space for a USB-A plug, realize that tons of NEW consumer devices still use that! Apple can convince its customer base to buy dongles, but will all Windows PC users be happy with that?
- ballenf 6y agoThat's increasingly not true with the single exception of the iPhone (and even it now uses USB-C for the adapter and Qi for the wireless charge protocol). Every other new device (iPads, laptop and desktop) is 100% USB-C. And, again, you don't even strictly need a lightning cable for your iPhone for most scenarios (airport charging type scenarios used to be the big exception in olden times). Some reviewers are guessing that iPhones will drop the wired charge port entirely at some point, so will become a moot point. And as for squeezing customers, switching away from the Lightning port would "squeeze" quite a few iPhone customers with lightning cables and docks and such strewn around their house. I just wish Apple had included a puck-type Qi charger and cable in the box. Could have kept the box pretty slim.
- gumby 6y ago> Except apple doesn't use standards. They use their own proprietary ports. Actually Apple is pretty standards compliant, sometimes excessively so. I have no illusion that they are doing this out of the goodness of their hearts, but the idea that they "don't use standards" is a canard. For video they long used open standards (DVI, Displayport, HDMI, now standard DisplayPort over Type C); they were one of the first to adoptt USB (much to the gnashing of teeth on the part of previous apple owners), the iPod originally used firewire; and lightning when it came out was the only insert-either-way connector (apple was on the USB board that designed Type C, but lightning predates type C) and now they use Type C (much to the gnashing of teeth of various parties). Their wireless chargers are Qi compatible, though their devices aren't :-(. Their USB implementations long required quite compliant devices rather than windows' "just install a flaky driver" leading to "hey this USB thingie doesn't work on Apple". I had hoped this year they'd ditch lightning for type C on at least the high end phones but no luck. On the software side, especially when they were the underdog they were quite standards compliant (image, music, video files, PDF, RTF etc) and are responsible for removing DRM from their music store. They didn't roll out their own formats until they were in a stronger position but have retained support for most of these old formats.
- vlan0 6y agoI think you may have overlooked the other side of those cables in your examples. While one side of the cable was FireWire or USB, the interface on the device was propriety. And that was true for over a decade worth of iPods, iPhones, and iPads.
- musicale 6y ago> While one side of the cable was FireWire or USB, the interface on the device was propriety The original iPod was FireWire-only. The 30-pin dock connector was developed to enable USB and FireWire connectivity as well as docking.
- gumby 6y agoI still have an original iPad and it had a big FireWire connector on it. It was FW on both ends. They rapidly switched to USB (w/30 pin at other end) in order to open up the PC market to the* iPod. * I refuse to follow Apples pretentious (proprietary?) refusal to use the article “the” with the iPod and the iPhone.
- ksec 6y ago>They use very advanced technology such as gallium nitride circuitry to miniaturise their chargers. Source for that? As far as I am aware GaN has yet made it into any of the Apple Chargers. ( And I really I am wrong on that )