9 ms·
It looks really cool and innovative, so congrats. However, it's pretty hard to evaluate since there's nothing concrete on the site and it's hard to imagine how
by crazygringo 6y ago
It looks really cool and innovative, so congrats.
However, it's pretty hard to evaluate since there's nothing concrete on the site and it's hard to imagine how they work.
What buttons do they have? How do they charge? How do you actually hear the audio when it doesn't actually go in your ear? Since it doesn't go in your ear, can someone next to you hear your audio -- is it private? What part swaps out? What's the battery life? What's the price? How much is the base price, and how much for each swappable part? Etc. etc. etc.
From the website alone (ignoring your HN title), I'd assume you haven't made these yet and you're just trying to gauge demand. But assuming you actually have made them... please show them off not just on the fashion side, but on the functionality side! Give us all the info please. :)
- Falling3 6y agoThey do sit in the ear like a low-profile earbud. You can kind of tell from some of the photos (but the video makes it more obvious) that these aren't using the pierced hole of the model's ear. They're sitting on the ear canal opening. The video also shows some of the interaction similar to an airpod tap. edit: Yea, I assumed wrong as several commenters pointed out.
- psidex 6y agoAre you sure? To me in the video it definitely seems like they are using an actual piercing, @ 1:05 you can see it swing away from her ear edit: In the pdf link above it states > "Ear Jewelry with Wireless Audio Device" provides a headset apparatus in which the audio device extends through the piercing in the wearer's ear, with the signal path passing through the piercing of the ear itself from a wireless communications device at the first end to the sound production unit at the opposite end.
- shaftway 6y agoAt 1:10 you can see someone attaching the backing to the earring
- scott_s 6y agoI don't think that's accurate. Looking at the patent application (courtesy of klyrs below, https://patents.google.com/patent/WO2017049261A1/en https://patents.google.com/patent/WO2017049261A1/en), it is indeed an earring that fits into a person's pierced ears. The speaker reaches up to and maybe into the ear canal, but unliked bud earphones, they are not held in place by the speaker. In the linked pdf, see pages 1, 37, 38, 39 and 41 for diagrams. In the background, they also say "a headset apparatus in which the audio device extends through the piercing in the wearer's ear."
- Aurum197 6y agoScott_s, that's right. We use the piercing of the ear. But we are also working on a clip-on version for those who don't have pierced ears. Also, as you said, the speaker reaches unto the ear canal (which helps support the speaker somewhat as well.)
- sweettea 6y agoYou might consider variants that use a conch piercing or a stretched earlobe piercing instead - I'm pretty sure, among the earring wearers of the affluent world, far more have stretched earlobes than have unpierced earlobes, and probably also more have conch piercings.
- Aurum197 6y agoConch piercing will likely be an easy adaptation, but the stretched earlobe variant sounds daunting. An interesting design challenge for sure.
- dddddaviddddd 6y agoCheck out the PDF of the patent for what look like all the details on how it works: https://patents.google.com/patent/WO2017049261A1/en https://patents.google.com/patent/WO2017049261A1/en
- Aurum197 6y agoOur production model uses a removable audio module. So the earrings can be worn with or without the audio.
- Aurum197 6y agoThanks crazygringo. To answer your questions: - We have made an MVP, and it works. - While the speaker doesn't go into the earcanal, it hovers over it. - It is private. Much like holding your phone to your ear while speaking. - The part that swaps out is the audiomodule. - The battery life isn't that great for the MVP; but we hope to improve it with our production model.
- hinkley 6y agoHave you spent much time looking at hearing aid designs? I think you'll find a lot of embodied wisdom on how to discreetly route audio into the ear canal.
- Aurum197 6y agoOne of the design features that we wanted to include in our main embodiment was: OPEN-EAR audio. Having something sitting inside the ear all day did not appeal to us; which is why we went with this design. There are a number of ways to disguise an in-canal hearable, but the "in-canal" option was something we wanted to avoid for all-day wear.
- oxfordmale 6y agoOPEN-EAR audio doesn't work in crowded cities, where you will find most of your demand.
- crazygringo 6y agoIf it's just podcasts or notifications it works fine 99% of the time. It's really just when the subway is pulling in, or an ambulance is going by, that you won't be able to hear. But as long as the button on the earring works as pause/play, it seems fine.
- Aurum197 6y agoTrue. There are situations where open-ear is not a great solution. But it works well for most of our use cases.