4 ms·
> Would people like it if it didn't have the star wars backdrop? Does the star wars backdrop even make that much sense? The bulk of the plot would work fine if
by gknoy 6y ago
> Would people like it if it didn't have the star wars backdrop? Does the star wars backdrop even make that much sense?
The bulk of the plot would work fine if it were space-bounty-hunter-with-angry-people-after-him, plus friends and a macguffin. Star Wars flavoring seems like the main way that this differentiates it from Cowboy Bebop (space bounty hunter in the solar system, hops between planets...).
A big part of why the show is good is the mysterious "what's under the mask" aspect. We've had Boba/Jango Fett for decades, but it's really neat to see the expansion of this lore about the mandalorian culture -- why they always stay masked, etc. SW nerds like me often find lore tidbits delicious.
The Mandalorian also happens to have ridiculously good production values compared to most shows -- I'm watching a movie in serial form. (See also Altered Carbon.) It also has interesting characters that I am curious about (both heroes and villains), with backstories I'd like to hear more about. THAT part doesn't need to be Star Wars. It could be samurai, or space privateers, or drama on a space station (DS9), and as long as it's done well, I'll want to watch it.
- klmadfejno 6y ago> See also Altered Carbon Well at least there's consistency. I thought Altered Carbon (the live action netflix version) was terrible too! For similar reasons. Really poorly executed action scenes. Underdeveloped drama.