3 ms·
I just printed out the linked paper and read it. It reminds me of other papers I have read in the behavioral genetics seminar of the psychology department of ou
by tokenadult 16y ago
I just printed out the linked paper and read it. It reminds me of other papers I have read in the behavioral genetics seminar of the psychology department of our local university.
http://www.psych.umn.edu/courses/fall10/psy8935/default.htm http://www.psych.umn.edu/courses/fall10/psy8935/default.htm
In the seminar, the assembled faculty members, graduate students, and interested members of the general public (I am in the last category) discuss research papers in psychology and try to make sense of what new papers are claiming. We look at the study methodologies to see if sample sizes are adequate, control groups are adequately assembled, and statistical analysis of the data has been done properly. If my recollection is correct, this particular paper was mentioned at least in passing at one of the seminar sessions last school year, when I began attending the seminar.
Looking at all the issues that one would look at while examining a research paper,
http://norvig.com/experiment-design.html http://norvig.com/experiment-design.html
it seems to me that this paper suggests an intriguing area for further research, but I would be doubtful of taking this to the bank by signing up for the training course mentioned in the paper in the expectation of increasing my IQ score (much less, in the expectation of increasing my performance in the real world outside the testing room). Working memory plainly has something to do with real world cognitive performance--all the intelligence researchers are looking at that issue these days--
http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=working+memory+IQ http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=working+memory+IQ
and working memory plainly can be improved by some forms of training. But there is a long way to go before we can say with confidence which form of training will have the most impact at least expense and inconvenience for the greatest number of human beings grappling with real-world cognitive tasks.
- barry-cotter 16y agoIf you're going to read a paper on n-back you should read gwern's FAQ on it. http://www.gwern.net/N-back%20FAQ.html http://www.gwern.net/N-back%20FAQ.html
- gwern 16y agoFor tokenadult, I would particularly point out http://www.gwern.net/N-back%20FAQ.html#criticism http://www.gwern.net/N-back%20FAQ.html#criticism