5 ms·
It's also super interesting for engineering reasons: - Maglev trains can be built at much lower cost - Other levitating transportation via the Meissner effect
by dheera 6y ago
It's also super interesting for engineering reasons:
- Maglev trains can be built at much lower cost
- Other levitating transportation via the Meissner effect
- Quantum computing
- Entertainment, theme parks
Lots of things I can think of.
- gipp 6y agoGP was talking specifically about the approach in the article, which requires massively high pressures to sustain, not superconduction in general. I don't think the required pressures are really practical for any of the things you listed.
- dheera 6y agoSure, it's not ready for those use cases yet, but the fact that it has been achieved at room temperature is a milestone, and those use cases are things that would benefit from room temperature superconductivity.
- hutzlibu 6y agoNo, it is not. Even though the goal at "room temperature" is technically met, it is misleading, because the goal "room temperature" meant superconducting under quite normal conditions to be of practical use. And when you have to apply that immense pressure it means we did not really come closer to superconducting in the normal world. Still a success, yes, but probably not a milestone, unless that discovery leads to other findings, but I do not see anything indicating such.
- gorgoiler 6y ago> they stress that the newfound compound will never find its way into lossless power lines or frictionless high-speed trains
- silvestrov 6y agoYou can transport electricity from wind mills from far, far away. The wind will always blow somewhere, so the storage problem goes away. Or solar power transported from the south to the north of US or EU. Superconductors are the ultimate joker in green energy.
- guenthert 6y agoYou can do this today and if you get energy for free, then the transportation-losses are of little significance (they are just a few percent to begin with). Superconductors won't play a role in energy transport until their installation and operational costs over their lifetime are less then the installation, operational costs and losses of legacy conductors.
- ben_w 6y ago> they are just a few percent to begin with To be more precise, losses are exponential with regard to distance. “A typical loss for 800 kV lines is 2.6% over 800 km”[0], which would be close to 60% losses between antipodes[2]. I think that’s still plausibly worth doing, given renewable prices[1], but it’s not great if you can avoid it. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-voltage_direct_current https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-voltage_direct_current [1] that said, I know nothing about the cost of making HV power grids, and it is entirely possible the costs I am ignorant of would make it a bad idea [2] but not, as autocorrupt first wrote, antipopes — cstross has nothing to do with the global electricity supply, to my knowledge